How & Where to Find the Right UGC Creator for Your Ad Goals (Fast)

Imagine you and your team hire a UGC creator based on their polished portfolio and professional look.

Their content looks great—high production value, trendy editing, the works. But the ads fall flat. The videos aren't resonating with your audience or driving conversions.

Why? The creator's style is too commercial and lacks authenticity, or their approach doesn't align with what actually converts for your specific product.

The solution isn't to keep hunting for creators based on surface-level qualities. It's about approaching UGC partnerships from a data-driven angle.

👋 Want to skip the knowledge and go straight to the solution? Get Motion's UGC Buddy to find the right UGC creator for you, then generate winning UGC scripts, creative briefs, and fresh concepts, all in one place.

How and where to find UGC creators: The new approach

UGC-based content is as old as commercially available products. We've all recommended products to friends and family and like to see others' opinions.

For businesses wanting native-feeling paid ads, finding creators has been a slow process involving:

• Manual outreach of tens or hundreds of creators.
• Searching hashtags for good UGC.
• Using marketplaces like TikTok Creator Marketplace, Collabstr, etc., to find experienced creators.

The new approach to finding creators uses dedicated tools like UGC Buddy, which automate creator sourcing to prioritize brand and campaign fit.

Let's break down why the traditional approach to finding UGC creators slows you down and how the new data-driven approach is better.

The old way of connecting with UGC creators (and why it’s slowing you down)

Manually connecting with UGC creators isn't built for scaling high-performance UGC campaigns. Here's why:

• Manual creator discovery is time-consuming. You need someone to monitor trends and feeds and be ready to spot a diamond in the rough.
  
  • It's also based on surface-level signals like follower counts and profile aesthetic instead of past ad performance.
• There's a lack of insight and no feedback loop into which creators actually drive Return on Ad Spend (ROAS). You just find someone who fits the bill and hope the partnership offers good returns.
• Manual outreach and partnership management typically happen across disjointed platforms. You DM a creator on the social media platform, send emails for formal negotiations, and use contracting software to finalize the deal.
• There's limited support for creative iteration, scripting, and trend matching. If you don't know what makes an ad work well with a specific UGC creator, how will you improve?

If you're using this approach, you might know the platforms for finding UGC content creators:

• Direct-access marketplaces like TikTok Creator Marketplace and Collabstr offer vetted talent pools with built-in performance metrics. These platforms streamline discovery but often command premium rates for top creators.
• Freelance platforms (Fiverr, Upwork) offer cost-effective options with detailed reviews and portfolios. While quality varies, these platforms excel for brands testing UGC without major commitments. However, the inconsistent quality also requires extensive vetting time.
• Manual discovery through Instagram hashtags and Facebook groups requires more effort—a time-intensive process with no quality guarantees. But it offers authentic connections and often better rates. This approach works best for brands willing to invest time in relationship-building.
• Enterprise solutions like AspireIQ and Tagger deliver comprehensive creator management tools with advanced filtering and performance tracking. These platforms suit larger brands managing multiple campaigns at the same time. But for smaller brands, the steep learning curve and monthly costs make them impractical.

UGC Buddy’s data-led approach to sourcing creators

Imagine automating most of the processes you use several platforms to do, all while using proven data.

UGC Buddy offers a modern, purpose-built solution for sourcing UGC content creators. It aggregates creator data across your platforms to identify the best matches for your specific requirements. Check it out here:

UGC Buddy improves every step of creator sourcing using a centralized AI-powered platform. How? You get:

• Creator discovery based on past content performance, which means you're not relying on arbitrary profile stats.
• Real-time brand fit that matches your tone and previous creative success.
• Integrated outreach, which includes briefing and tracking performance within a single workflow.
• Data-informed recommendations so teams know which creators produce high-converting content before they even reach out.
• A weekly personalized strategy review complete with performance analysis, emerging trends, and actionable concept recommendations.

Let's see how this approach compares to traditional UGC creator sourcing:

How to evaluate creator fit

Finding the right UGC creator isn't just about follower count. It's about matching specific qualities to your campaign goals. If you want to cut to the chase, check out this short video covering the basics:

Otherwise, here's a more detailed framework to evaluate potential creators:

1. Vertical expertise and category knowledge

• Look for creators who understand your industry's language and pain points.
• Check their content history for experience with similar products/services.
• Review how they handle technical specs and feature explanations.

2. Technical production skills

• Video quality: Clean footage, proper lighting, and professional sound.
• Editing capabilities: Smooth transitions, engaging pacing, and platform-appropriate formatting.
• Brand consistency: Ability to match your visual guidelines while maintaining authenticity.

3. Storytelling and ad hook creation

• First 3 seconds: How quickly do they grab attention?
• Message clarity: Can they effectively communicate value propositions?
• Call-to-action (CTA) strength: Do they drive viewers to take action?

4. Audience alignment

• Engagement quality: Comments and shares that indicate genuine interest.
• Response patterns: How their audience reacts to promotional content.
• Values match: Alignment with your brand's mission and voice.

UGC Buddy simplifies this evaluation process by analyzing creators' historical performance data. The platform's AI examines thousands of data points across these criteria, predicting which creators are most likely to drive results for your specific campaign goals. Instead of manual vetting, you get instant insights into creator fit based on proven performance metrics.

This data-driven approach means you can focus on building relationships with creators who are statistically more likely to deliver ROI, rather than gambling on surface-level metrics.

The value of long-term relationships with UGC creators (and how to build them)

Finding a great UGC creator isn't the finish line—it's where the real optimization begins. The most successful brands build lasting partnerships with creators who consistently deliver high-performing content. Here's how to make that happen:

Create performance feedback loops

Performance data drives better creative decisions. Instead of guessing what works, establish a systematic approach to testing and optimization:

1. Track key metrics for each piece of UGC content:
   
   • View-through rate (VTR)
   • Click-through rate (CTR)
   • Cost per acquisition (CPA)
   • Return on ad spend (ROAS)
2. Break down successful content by creative elements:
   
   • Hook timing and type
   • Key messages and claims
   • Visual style and pacing
   • Call-to-action placement
3. Use UGC Buddy's analytics dashboard to automatically:
   
   • Compare creator performance across campaigns
   • Identify winning creative patterns
   • Generate data-backed improvement recommendations

Scale successful UGC partnerships

Once you've identified top-performing creators, scale their success with these proven strategies:

1. Provide detailed creative briefs.
   
   • Share specific performance data from past wins.
   • Outline exactly which elements drove success.
   • Set clear KPI targets for new content.
2. Streamline content development.
   
   • Use AI-powered scripting tools to maintain consistent messaging.
   • Create template-based workflows for faster production.
   • Build a library of proven hooks and formats.
3. Set campaigns up for success.
   
   • Pre-approve specific creative directions.
   • Establish clear feedback channels.
   • Schedule regular performance reviews.

UGC Buddy simplifies this entire process by centralizing creator management, performance tracking, and optimization in one platform. This means teams can focus on scaling what works instead of getting lost in spreadsheets and multiple tools.

‍

How to find UGC creators FAQs

What is a UGC creator and how do they differ from traditional influencers?

UGC creators specialize in making authentic, conversion-focused content for brands to use in their own ads, while traditional influencers promote products directly to their large personal following.

How much should I expect to pay UGC creators?

The rate ranges vary a lot—judging by the r/UGCcreators subreddit. But at a minimum, expect ranges to vary based on experience:

• Beginner creators: around $50-100 per video
• Mid-level creators: around $150-500 per video
• Established creators: sometimes $500+ per video

Other factors like project complexity and usage rights can add more to the cost.

What information should I include in a UGC creator brief?

A UGC creator brief should include:

• Your campaign goals
• Key Performance Indicator (KPI) targets
• Key messaging points
• Brand guidelines
• Technical requirements (video length, format, etc.)
• Specific do's and don'ts—plus examples of successful UGC content that matches your vision

How many UGC creators should I work with for a campaign?

It's a good idea to start out with 3–5 UGC creators for a single campaign. With multiple creators, you can compare performance and test specific UGC styles, then scale up what works best.

‍