Tutorial creative analysis ·7 min ·Recorded Apr 2026

We Analyzed $500K In Meta Ads To Find Hooks & Formats That Always Win

This video presents an analysis of 550,000 ads from 6,000 brands to determine which creative variables (hooks, ad types, visual styles) perform best on Meta. The speaker introduces a two-metric framework — "Hit Rate" and "Spend Use Ratio" — to evaluate creative effectiveness beyond simple win/loss metrics. The core findings suggest that lower-effort, high-volume creative testing is more effective for discovery, while high-production creative is better suited for scaling already-proven concepts.

What's discussed, in order

3 named frameworks

01 Creative Performance Evaluation Metrics (Hit Rate × Spend Use Ratio)
A two-metric system for evaluating the performance and efficiency of creative variables.
presenter's own (Motion) · ~00:55Play
02 Scale Formats / Volatile Formats / Big Swings
A three-tier categorization of visual formats based on Hit Rate and Spend Use Ratio.
presenter's own · ~04:52Play
03 Harvesting vs. Planting
A seasonal strategy framing — during high-intent buying windows (BFCM), prioritize direct-response "harvesting" ads over brand-building "planting" ads.
presenter's own · ~05:58Play

What's actually believed — in their own words

A high-production, "Hollywood blockbuster" ad can fail and be outperformed by a simple, low-effort ad.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · observation 00:06 #

550,000 ads from 6,000 brands across industries were analyzed.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · data-backed 00:25 #

A Spend Use Ratio above 1.0 means a variable is punching above its weight.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · definition 01:07 #

Offer only" hooks ranked near the top of the list for both hit rate and spend use.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · data-backed 01:56 #

Bold claims and shocking statements ranked surprisingly low on spend use.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · data-backed 02:17 #

When every ad opens with the same bold claim, it stops being bold and signals "this is an ad.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · opinion 02:31 #

Urgency and FOMO are timeless advertising fundamentals, not fleeting trends.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · opinion 02:46 #

What looks like a winning ad and what actually gets spend are two very different things.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · observation 03:06 #

Text-only ads, product images with overlays, and GIFs lead to more winners than high-production ads.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · data-backed 03:17 #

Low-effort ads work because they communicate value in under two seconds with no visual noise.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · hypothesis 03:24 #

Meta Ads is a numbers game; winning is rare, so you want to maximize shots on target.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · observation 03:47 #

The volume of UGC ads absolutely dwarfs high production.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · data-backed 03:54 #

High-production ads are not built for discovery; they should be used to scale what's already proven.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · opinion 04:05 #

Unboxing led visual formats on hit rate, with nearly one in ten ads becoming winners (~9.83%).

Speaker 1 · 2026 · data-backed 04:28 #

Behind-the-scenes and founder ads had hit rates above 8%.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · data-backed 04:32 #

The top four visual styles for spend use ratio (celebrity, letter, unconventional text placement, post-it) didn't crack the top 25 for hit rate.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · data-backed 04:40 #

POV had one of the highest hit rates but the lowest spend use ratio in the chart.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · data-backed 04:43 #

Offer-first banners and demos are scale formats — reliable and widely deployed.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · data-backed 04:52 #

Unboxing and POV win often but plateau quickly under the algorithm.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · data-backed 05:13 #

Celebrity ads are low-hit-rate but high-spend-ratio "big swings" — rare but big when they win.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · data-backed 05:21 #

The healthiest ad accounts have a mix of scale formats, volatile formats, and big swings.

Speaker 1 · 2026 · opinion 05:32 #

The do's and don'ts pulled from the session

Do this
  • Prioritize low-effort ads to keep your ad account running and enable faster testing. 05:39 #
  • Use high-production ads to scale concepts that have already been proven. 04:07 #
  • During BFCM/holiday windows, "harvest" with direct-response ads rather than "plant" with brand-building. 05:58 #
  • Build a portfolio with a mix of scale formats (demos, offer-first banners), volatile formats (unboxing, POV), and big swings (celebrity). 05:32 #
  • Lean on advertising fundamentals like urgency and FOMO hooks. 02:52 #
  • Run offer-only hooks, especially during promotional windows. 01:56 #
Don't do this
  • Don't assume high-production creative will automatically perform. 00:08 #
  • Don't overuse bold claims or shocking statements as hooks. 02:30 #
  • Don't use slow, expensive creative for initial testing/discovery. 04:05 #

Numbers quoted in this talk

550,000 ads analyzed
Speaker 1 · 2026 · 00:25 #
6,000 brands across industries
Speaker 1 · 2026 · 00:25 #
Unboxing hit rate ≈ 9.83% (nearly 1 in 10)
Speaker 1 · 2026 · 04:28 #
Behind-the-scenes and founder ads hit rates >8%
Speaker 1 · 2026 · 04:32 #
Hook hit rates (from on-screen table): Newness 11.37%, Sale announcement 11.35%, Price anchor 10.89%, Urgency 9.73%, Announcement 9.59%, Offer only 9.29%, FOMO 9.20%, Bold claim 7.19%
Slide #10 · 2026 · 01:40 #
Hook spend use ratios (from on-screen table): Giveaway 2.29, Price anchor 2.00, Announcement 1.57, Event announcement 1.57, Offer only 1.42, Urgency 1.31, FOMO 1.22
Slide #10 · 2026 · 01:47 #
Visual format spend use ratios: Celebrity 2.17, Letter 1.87, Unconventional text placement 1.44, Post-it 1.38, Offer-first banner 1.34, Unboxing 1.32
Slide #19 · 2026 · 04:38 #

Everything referenced on-screen and by name

People mentioned (excluding speakers listed above)

  • Gordon Ramsay — Appears in a Hexclad celebrity ad example (05:22).

Brands / companies referenced

  • Meta — Platform where analyzed ads ran.
  • Ridge Wallet — Featured as the "perfect ad that tanked" opening example.
  • DTC Masterclass — Featured as the low-effort ad that beat Ridge Wallet's.
  • AG1 — Featured in low-effort ad montages.
  • Jones Road — Featured in low-effort ad montages.
  • Hexclad — Featured in low-effort and celebrity (Gordon Ramsay) ad examples.
  • Supergoop! — Featured as a hi-fi ad example.
  • Caraway — Featured in offer-first banner example.
  • Spudsy — Featured in final low-effort ad montage.

Tools / products referenced (excluding Motion)

  • Adobe After Effects — Referenced as a time-intensive export step for ad production.
  • Google Docs — Shown as the storyboarding tool for the Ridge Wallet ad script.

External frameworks / concepts cited

14 ads referenced

Show all 14 ads with extraction details
Ad #1 — Ridge Wallet Car Chase
Ridge Wallet ·Video ·00:06
Duration shown in this video
4 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
A man in tactical gear jumps from the side of a moving black SUV onto the trunk of another moving black SUV on a highway.
Product / pitch
A wallet that is as tough as you are.
Key on-screen text
"A WALLET AS TOUGH AS YOU ARE"
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
High-fi, cinematic, action-movie style.
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
Action sequence establishing toughness → product benefit statement.
Why shown in this video
An example of a high-production, seemingly "perfect" ad that ultimately failed to perform.
Speaker's take
"It looks like a Hollywood blockbuster. And this ad absolutely tanks."
Ad #2 — DTC Masterclass Sticky Note
DTC Masterclass ·Video ·00:12
Duration shown in this video
2 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
A hand places a pink sticky note onto a white surface.
Product / pitch
A course for B2B marketers to learn from DTC strategies.
Key on-screen text
"DTC Masterclass", "B2B can learn from DTC", "Click below to buy our course"
Key spoken lines
"Check it out, guys."
Visual style
Lo-fi, user-generated feel.
CTA / offer (if shown)
"Click below to buy our course"
Narrative arc
Simple statement → CTA.
Why shown in this video
An example of a simple, low-effort ad that outperformed the high-production ad.
Speaker's take
"And even worse, it gets beat out by this."
Ad #3 — Motion Creative Benchmarks Report (Top Visual Styles)
Motion ·Website screenshot ·00:35
Duration shown in this video
2 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
N/A
Product / pitch
A report on top-performing creative benchmarks for advertising.
Key on-screen text
"Top visual styles", "UGC Overlay", "Greenscreen", "Would you rather?", "Listicle", "Letter", "Unconventional text placement", "ASMR", "Founder", "Sign".
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Webpage UI with ad thumbnails.
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
N/A
Why shown in this video
To introduce the data and analysis that the video is based on.
Speaker's take
"We found the top visual styles..."
Ad #4 — Motion Creative Benchmarks Report (Top Hooks & Headlines)
Motion ·Website screenshot ·00:36
Duration shown in this video
1 second
Hook (first 3 sec)
N/A
Product / pitch
A report on top-performing creative benchmarks for advertising.
Key on-screen text
"Top hooks & headlines", "Confession", "Offer only", "Storytelling", "Question", "POV", "Listicle", "How to", "Explainer".
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Webpage UI with ad thumbnails.
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
N/A
Why shown in this video
To introduce the data and analysis that the video is based on.
Speaker's take
"...hooks, headlines..."
Ad #5 — Motion Creative Benchmarks Report (Top Asset Types)
Motion ·Website screenshot ·00:38
Duration shown in this video
2 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
N/A
Product / pitch
A report on top-performing creative benchmarks for advertising.
Key on-screen text
"Top asset types", "UGC", "High production", "Product image with text", "Lifestyle image with text", "Text only", "GIF", "UGC mashup", "Animation", "Hybrid".
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Webpage UI with ad thumbnails.
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
N/A
Why shown in this video
To introduce the data and analysis that the video is based on.
Speaker's take
"...and asset types..."
Ad #6 — Black Friday / Christmas Shopping Montage
Unknown brand (stock footage) ·Video montage ·02:05
Duration shown in this video
8 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
A montage of people shopping, sales signs, and gift-giving.
Product / pitch
N/A (illustrative footage)
Key on-screen text
"BLACK FRIDAY", "CHRISTMAS", "AUDIENCES ARE IN BUY-NOW MODE"
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Stock-footage, polished.
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
N/A
Why shown in this video
To illustrate the time period (BFCM) when the data was collected, explaining why direct-offer ads performed well.
Speaker's take
"Now, we did our data collection between Black Friday and Christmas. So hooks that signal immediacy and get straight to the point... could actually be at an advantage with shoppers already in buy-now mode."
Ad #7 — "Bold Claim" / "Shocking Statement" Montage
Multiple unknown brands ·Split-screen TikTok-style video montage ·02:20
Duration shown in this video
4 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
Three different creators speaking directly to the camera.
Product / pitch
Various products, likely health/wellness and home goods.
Key on-screen text
"Busting this BIG MYTH", "isn't dirty", "doing it wrong.", "I'm not trying to live forever", "to make later", "enough was enough,", "say I'm"
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
UGC, TikTok style.
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
N/A
Why shown in this video
To provide examples of "bold claim" and "shocking statement" hooks that performed poorly in the data, contrary to popular belief.
Speaker's take
"These are the hooks that I think of when I hear the word 'hook' because they dominate my social feed."
Ad #8 — High-Production Ad Montage
Multiple unknown brands ·Video montage ·03:11
Duration shown in this video
4 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
A montage of a car chase, a luxury perfume ad, and a soda can opening.
Product / pitch
Various (car/action, luxury perfume, beverage).
Key on-screen text
"ÉCLAT DE NUIT", "Embrace the Night's Splendor", "PARIS", "WWW.ECLATDENUIT.COM", "cosmo", "Solar Citrus", "A Universe of Flavor", "SMOOTH"
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
High-fi, polished, cinematic.
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
N/A
Why shown in this video
To illustrate the types of high-production ads that seem like they should win but are often outperformed by simpler formats.
Speaker's take
"High production videos, beautiful photography, fancy motion graphics, these seem like they should win..."
Ad #9 — Low-Effort Ad Montage (Text/Image/GIF)
AG1, Jones Road, Hexclad ·Image montage (stills of phone screens showing ads) ·03:17
Duration shown in this video
4 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
N/A
Product / pitch
Wellness supplement, makeup, and knives.
Key on-screen text
"The Simple Morning Routine for Multitasking Moms.", "AG1", "Need to look presentable but only have a few minutes? My full routine below", "JONES ROAD", "HEXCLAD", "SAME KNIVES."
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Lo-fi, static image, text overlay.
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
N/A
Why shown in this video
To show examples of the low-effort ad types (text-only, product images with overlays, GIFs) that actually lead to more winners.
Speaker's take
"...but in reality, text-only ads, product images with overlays, and GIFs, they all lead to more winners."
Ad #10 — UGC Ad Montage
Multiple unknown brands ·Video montage (multiple UGC-style clips) ·03:54
Duration shown in this video
4 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
A collage of various user-generated style videos.
Product / pitch
Various consumer goods.
Key on-screen text
"See what fancy restaurants are in your area this week", "Here's what flooring installation costs in my area", "wander"
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
UGC, lo-fi, TikTok style.
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
N/A
Why shown in this video
To illustrate the high volume of UGC ads compared to high-production ads.
Speaker's take
"This is why the volume of UGC ads absolutely dwarfs high production."
Ad #11 — High-Production Ad (Supergoop!)
Supergoop! ·Video ·03:59
Duration shown in this video
3 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
A tube of sunscreen floats in a cloudy sky.
Product / pitch
Sunscreen stick.
Key on-screen text
"supergoop!", "unseen sunscreen stick"
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
High-fi, polished, studio product shots.
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
N/A
Why shown in this video
As an example of a high-production ad that can still win, but plays a specific role (scaling, not discovery).
Speaker's take
"Hi-fi ads can still win, they just play a specific role."
Ad #12 — Offer-First Banner & Demo Ad Examples
Caraway, unknown makeup brand ·Split-screen, phone mockups showing two different ads. ·04:52
Duration shown in this video
3 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
One ad shows a product shot with a price, the other shows a woman applying makeup.
Product / pitch
Cookware set and makeup.
Key on-screen text
(Left) "SAVE $300 WITH THE 12-PIECE SET", "$497 - $532 - $599", "$699". (Right) "for like contouring and bronzing", "think it's going to be perfect"
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished product shot (left), UGC/demo (right).
CTA / offer (if shown)
"SAVE $300"
Narrative arc
N/A
Why shown in this video
To provide examples of "scale formats" (offer-first banners and demos) that rank well on both hit rate and spend use.
Speaker's take
"First, the styles that rank well on both charts, offer-first banners, demos, these are your scale formats."
Ad #13 — Celebrity Ad (Gordon Ramsay for Hexclad)
Hexclad ·UGC-style video featuring a celebrity. ·05:22
Duration shown in this video
3 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
Gordon Ramsay in a kitchen, speaking to the camera.
Product / pitch
Cookware used by a famous chef.
Key on-screen text
"HERE ARE THE 4 REASONS I ONLY USE HEXCLAD IN MY KITCHENS"
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
UGC, celebrity endorsement.
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
N/A
Why shown in this video
As an example of a "big swing" ad type (celebrity ad) that has a low hit rate but a high spend ratio when it does win.
Speaker's take
"...ads with low hit rates and high spend use ratios, like celebrity ads, are your big swings."
Ad #14 — Low-Effort UGC/Image Ads (Final Montage)
Spudsy, AG1, unknown skincare, Jones Road ·Montage of four different ads on phone screens. ·06:07
Duration shown in this video
3 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
N/A
Product / pitch
Various consumer goods (snacks, supplements, skincare, makeup).
Key on-screen text
"@SPUDSYFOODS", "Like how do I pick a favorite they all smell so good", "Absolutely Obsessed With My AG1 Welcome Kit", "Save 20% with a 3 month subscription", "Collect the latest beauty award winner, Miracle Balm, today.", "I SEE THE MOST PUT-TOGETHER MOMS USING THIS KIT."
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
UGC, lifestyle, product image with text.
CTA / offer (if shown)
"Save 20% with a 3 month subscription"
Narrative arc
N/A
Why shown in this video
To illustrate the types of low-lift ads that should be prioritized for testing and harvesting during peak buying seasons.
Speaker's take
"In some cases, these end up being the same low-lift ads you should be doing anyways."

27 slides, in order

Show all 27 slides with full slide content
Slide #1 — Title card
title-only ·00:02 ·Play
Title / header text
THE PERFECT AD
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...you just launched the perfect ad."
Slide #2 — Google Doc Screenshot
screenshot-with-annotations ·00:03 ·Play
Title / header text
Ridge Wallet Car Chase Ad
Body content
A screenshot of a Google Docs storyboard for an ad. It includes columns for shots, dialogue, and visual descriptions.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
• Image of a desert car chase. • Image of a man driving a car.
Annotations / visual emphasis
Four flame emojis are overlaid on the screenshot.
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"The script, it's fire."
Slide #3 — Title card
title-only ·00:08 ·Play
Title / header text
AND THI
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...and this ad absolutely tanks."
Slide #4 — Title card
title-only ·00:11 ·Play
Title / header text
AND EVEN
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"And even worse..."
Slide #5 — Title card
title-only ·00:12 ·Play
Title / header text
IT GETS BEA
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...it gets beat out by this."
Slide #6 — Title card
title-only ·00:32 ·Play
Title / header text
WHAT ADS ARE WINNING MOST OFTEN
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...to answer the question, what ads are winning most often?"
Slide #7 — Webpage Screenshot
screenshot-with-annotations ·00:35 ·Play
Title / header text
Top visual styles
Body content
A screenshot of the Motion app webpage showing various ad styles.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
• UGC Overlay • Greenscreen • Would you rather? • Listicle • Letter • Unconventional text placement • ASMR • Founder • Sign
Annotations / visual emphasis
The page scrolls down to show "Top hooks & headlines" and "Top asset types".
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"We found the top visual styles, hooks, headlines, and asset types..."
Slide #8 — Handwritten Notes
image+text ·00:55 ·Play
Title / header text
None used
Body content
• WE LOOKED AT 2 METRICS: • HIT RATE & SPEND USE RATIO
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
• An arrow points from "HIT RATE" to handwritten text: "HOW OFTEN THE VARIABLE PRODUCES A WINNER?" • An arrow points from "& SPEND USE RATIO" to handwritten text: "WHEN THE VARIABLE IS USED, HOW LIKELY IS IT TO GET SPEND?" • An arrow points from the "SPEND USE RATIO" line to handwritten text: "OVER 1.0 = GOOD" and "UNDER 1.0 = OVERUSED RELATIVE TO RESULTS" • An equals sign is drawn under "HIGH HIT RATE & HIGH SPEND RATIO" pointing to "WINNING VARIABLE!!!" • An equals sign is drawn under "HIGH HIT RATE & LOW SPEND RATIO" pointing to "VARIABLE IS VOLATILE" • An equals sign is drawn under "LOW HIT RATE & HIGH SPEND RATIO" pointing to "MID-TIER AD RELIABLY DECENT"
Reveal state
The text and annotations are revealed sequentially.
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"We looked at two metrics: hit rate and spend use ratio."
Slide #9 — Title card
title-only ·1:38 ·Play
Title / header text
TOP AD HOOKS
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...let's get into the top ad hooks."
Slide #10 — Hook Headline Tactics Table
table ·1:40, revisited 1:47 ·Play
Title / header text
Hook headline tactics
Body content
A table showing performance metrics for different ad hooks.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
State 1 (Hit rate view, 1:40)
• Columns: Hook headline tactics, Winners, Mid-range, Hit rate (%) • Rows shown: Newness (11.37%), Sale announcement (11.35%), Price anchor (10.89%), Urgency (9.73%), Announcement (9.59%), Offer only (9.29%), FOMO (9.20%), New product announcement (8.76%), Confession (8.74%), Exclusivity (8.44%), Curiosity (7.77%), Giveaway (7.69%), Event announcement (7.62%), Bold claim (7.19%), and more.
State 2 (Spend use view, 1:47)
• Columns: Hook headline tactics, % Creatives, % Spend, Spend use ratio • Rows shown: Giveaway (2.29), Price anchor (2.00), Announcement (1.57), Event announcement (1.57), Offer only (1.42), Confession (1.41), Urgency (1.31), Curiosity (1.29), FOMO (1.22), Wordplay (1.20), Contrast (1.20), Myth busting (1.14), Call to action first (1.12), and more.
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
• At 1:57, the "Offer only" row is highlighted in yellow in the Spend use view. • At 2:17, the "Shocking statement" and "Bold claim" rows are highlighted in yellow in the Spend use view. • At 2:45, the "Urgency" and "FOMO" rows are highlighted in yellow in the Hit rate view.
Reveal state
The view toggles from "Hit rate" to "Spend use".
Re-reference
The slide is revisited multiple times with different rows highlighted to support the speaker's points.
Speaker's framing
"This chart shows 25 hook tactics and how many winning ads and mid-range ads actually use them."
Slide #11 — Creative Benchmarks Report Screenshot
screenshot-with-annotations ·1:51 ·Play
Title / header text
CREATIVE BENCHMARKS 2026
Body content
A screenshot of the Motion app's "Creative Benchmarks 2026" report landing page.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
The page is shown scrolling down.
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...check out Motion's free 2026 Creative Benchmarks report..."
Slide #12 — Holiday Shopping Graphic
image+text ·2:05 ·Play
Title / header text
BLACK FRIDAY, CHRISTMAS
Body content
A dotted line connects the two headers.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
Various images of people shopping and holiday scenes appear under each header.
Annotations / visual emphasis
Text appears over the dotted line: "AUDIENCES ARE IN BUY-NOW MODE".
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"Now, we did our data collection between Black Friday and Christmas..."
Slide #13 — Text Overlay
title-only ·2:31 ·Play
Title / header text
WHEN EVERY AD OPENS WITH THE SAME BOLD CLAIM IT'S NO LONGER THAT BOLD
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"When every ad opens with the same bold claim, it's no longer that bold."
Slide #14 — Title card
title-only ·3:00 ·Play
Title / header text
THE TOP AD TYPES
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"Now, ad types."
Slide #15 — Text Overlay
title-only ·3:20 ·Play
Title / header text
THEY ALL LEAD TO MORE WINNERS.
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...text-only ads, product images with overlays, and GIFs, they all lead to more winners."
Slide #16 — Text Overlay
title-only ·3:47 ·Play
Title / header text
HOW META DISTRIBUTES YOUR AD BUDGET
Body content
A graphic shows a dollar sign between a winning ad and several losing ads.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"As we talked about in this video, Meta Ads is a numbers game..."
Slide #17 — Hi-Fi Ads Graphic
image+text ·3:59 ·Play
Title / header text
None used
Body content
• HI-FI ADS CAN STILL WIN • THEY JUST PLAY A SPECIFIC ROLE
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
A high-production ad for a sunscreen stick.
Annotations / visual emphasis
An arrow points from the text to the ad example.
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"High-production ads can absolutely win. They just have a specific role."
Slide #18 — Title card
title-only ·4:18 ·Play
Title / header text
TOP VISUAL STYLES
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"Now, let's look at the visual styles."
Slide #19 — Visual Format Table
table ·4:21, revisited 4:38 ·Play
Title / header text
Visual format
Body content
A table showing performance metrics for different visual ad formats.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
State 1 (Hit rate view, 4:21)
• Columns: Visual format, Winners, Mid-range, Hit rate (%) • Rows shown: Offer-first banner (8.68%), Demo (8.11%), Testimonial (6.57%), Headline (6.26%), Montage (7.02%), Before & after (6.07%), Listicle (5.30%), Split screen (5.62%), Us vs them (6.52%), Unboxing (9.83%), and more.
State 2 (Spend use view, 4:38)
• Columns: Visual format, % Creatives, % Spend, Spend use ratio • Rows shown: Celebrity (2.17), Letter (1.87), Unconventional text placement (1.44), Post it (1.38), Offer-first banner (1.34), Unboxing (1.32), ChatGPT (1.29), Social post mockup (1.25), Sign (1.24), and more.
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
• At 4:30, the "Unboxing" row is highlighted in yellow in the Hit rate view. • At 4:35, the "Founder" row is highlighted in yellow in the Hit rate view. • At 4:40, the top four rows ("Celebrity", "Letter", "Unconventional text placement", "Post it") are highlighted in yellow in the Spend use view. • At 4:44, the "POV" row is highlighted in yellow in the Spend use view.
Reveal state
The view toggles from "Hit rate" to "Spend use".
Re-reference
The slide is revisited with different rows highlighted.
Speaker's framing
"This chart tells a more nuanced story..."
Slide #20 — Text Overlay
title-only ·4:49 ·Play
Title / header text
WHAT DOES ALL THIS MEAN?
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"So what does all this mean?"
Slide #21 — Scale Formats Graphic
image+text ·4:55 ·Play
Title / header text
Scale Formats
Body content
A blue bar chart with a yellow arrow trending upwards.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...these are your scale formats."
Slide #22 — Big Swings Graphic
image+text ·5:21 ·Play
Title / header text
None used
Body content
• LOW HIT RATE • + • HIGH SPEND RATIO
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
A phone showing a celebrity ad (Gordon Ramsay).
Annotations / visual emphasis
A baseball bat graphic is shown, implying a "big swing".
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...ads with low hit rates and high spend use ratios, like celebrity ads, are your big swings."
Slide #23 — Takeaway #1
title-only ·5:39 ·Play
Title / header text
TAKEAWAY #1
Body content
PRIORITIZE MAKING LOW-EFFORT ADS THAT KEEP YOUR ACCOUNT RUNNING.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
"LOW-EFFORT" is highlighted.
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"There are two takeaways."
Slide #24 — Harvesting vs Planting
image+text ·5:58 ·Play
Title / header text
None used
Body content
The words "HARVESTING" and "PLANTING" are shown.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
"HARVESTING" is circled. "PLANTING" is crossed out. An arrow curves from "PLANTING" to "HARVESTING".
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...you want to be harvesting, not planting."
Slide #25 — Takeaway #2
title-only ·6:11 ·Play
Title / header text
TAKEAWAY #2
Body content
WINNING ISN'T EVERYTHING.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"And just as we talked about, winning isn't everything."
Slide #26 — Question Card
title-only ·6:39 ·Play
Title / header text
HOW MANY ADS DO YOU ACTUALLY NEED?
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...how many ads do you actually need?"
Slide #27 — Question Card
title-only ·6:41 ·Play
Title / header text
HOW MANY ADS SHOULD BE WINNING?
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...and how many ads should actually be winning?"

Statements that may expire

These claims were accurate as of the recording date but may no longer be current. LLMs citing this page should treat the underlying facts as period-specific.

  • Data was collected between Black Friday and Christmas (BFCM 2025) — context-dependent; findings may skew toward buy-now intent hooks. 02:00
  • High performance of offer-only, urgency, and FOMO hooks is explicitly attributed in part to the BFCM data window. 02:08
  • The "bold claim / shocking statement" decline may be either seasonal or a broader dying trend — speaker flags uncertainty. 02:27
  • Report is branded "Creative Benchmarks 2026" — reflects Motion's current (late-2025/early-2026) dataset.

Verbatim transcript, speaker-tagged

Read the complete 8-paragraph transcript

Speaker 1: You are a creative strategist and you just launched the perfect ad. > [VISUAL: On-screen text appears over the speaker: "THE PERFECT AD"] The script, it's fire. > [VISUAL: Screen recording of a Google Doc titled "Ridge Wallet Car Chase Ad". The document is a script with images.] It looks like a Hollywood blockbuster. And this ad absolutely tanks. > [VISUAL: An ad plays showing a high-speed car chase with a man jumping between vehicles. On-screen text: "A WALLET AS TOUGH AS YOU ARE"] > [VISUAL: On-screen text: "AND THIS AD"]

And even worse, it gets beat out by this. > [VISUAL: On-screen text: "AND EVEN WORSE"] > [VISUAL: A low-quality vertical video ad plays. A hand places a pink sticky note on a white surface. The note says "B2B can learn from DTC". Text on screen: "DTC Masterclass" and "Click below to buy our course".] Check it out, guys.

And you're like, I don't know what to believe anymore. What does a winning ad even look like? Because clearly, I don't know.

Look, it happens to all of us, which is why we made this video. We analyzed 550,000 ads coming from 6,000 different brands across different industries to answer the question, what ads are winning most often? > [VISUAL: On-screen text overlays the speaker: "WHAT ADS ARE WINNING MOST OFTEN"] We found the top visual styles, hooks, headlines, and asset types. > [VISUAL: Screen recording of a webpage titled "Creative Benchmarks 2026" on motionapp.com. The page scrolls through sections titled "Top visual styles", "Top hooks & headlines", and "Top asset types", each with a carousel of example ads.] But more importantly, we came away with a single insight that will completely change how you approach your ad strategy. More on that at the end of the video.

Now, before we get into the anatomy of a winning ad, I need to explain how we conducted our research to determine the top performing creative variables. > [VISUAL: On-screen text appears on a background of lined paper: "WE LOOKED AT 2 METRICS:"] We looked at two metrics: hit rate and spend use ratio. > [VISUAL: Text appears on the paper: "HIT RATE & SPEND USE RATIO"] Hit rate answers how often did this variable produce a winner? > [VISUAL: An arrow points from "HIT RATE" with the text: "HOW OFTEN THE VARIABLE PRODUCES A WINNER?"] While spend use answers, when this variable is used, how likely is it to get spend? > [VISUAL: An arrow points from "& SPEND USE RATIO" with the text: "WHEN THE VARIABLE IS USED, HOW LIKELY IS IT TO GET SPEND?"] If it's above 1.0, it's punching above its weight. > [VISUAL: An arrow points from the "SPEND USE RATIO" line with the text: "OVER 1.0 = GOOD"] But if it's below 1.0, it's overused relative to results. > [VISUAL: More text appears: "UNDER 1.0 = OVERUSED RELATIVE TO RESULTS"] When a hook or format scored high with both metrics, that's the sign of a winning variable. > [VISUAL: New text appears on the paper: "HIGH HIT RATE & HIGH SPEND RATIO = WINNING VARIABLE!!!"] When the hit rate was high but the spend use ratio was low, it's more volatile, signaling that an ad occasionally pops off but doesn't score reliably. > [VISUAL: New text appears on the paper: "HIGH HIT RATE & LOW SPEND RATIO = VARIABLE IS VOLATILE"] Contrast this then with low hit rates and high spend use. That's indicative of a mid-tier workhorse sort of ad. Nothing special, but reliable and consistent. > [VISUAL: New text appears on the paper: "LOW HIT RATE & HIGH SPEND RATIO = MID-TIER AD RELIABLY DECENT"] Okay, with that out of the way, let's get into the top ad hooks. > [VISUAL: A solid blue screen with white text: "TOP AD HOOKS"] This chart shows 25 hook tactics and how many winning ads and mid-range ads actually use them. > [VISUAL: Screen recording of the Motion app webpage. A table is shown titled "Hook headline tactics" with columns for "Winners", "Mid-range", and "Hit rate (%)". The cursor points to the "Winners" and "Mid-range" columns.] Then this toggle here lets you switch between our two metrics. > [VISUAL: The cursor clicks a toggle switch on the webpage, changing the view from "Hit rate" to "Spend use". The table columns change to "% Creatives", "% Spend", and "Spend use ratio".] I'm going to break this down for you, but if you'd like to run through it yourself, check out Motion's free 2026 Creative Benchmarks report at the link in the description. > [VISUAL: Screen recording of the Motion app "Creative Benchmarks 2026" landing page.] Offer-only hooks ranked near the top of the list for hit rate and spend use. > [VISUAL: Screen recording of the "Spend use" table. The row for "Offer only" is highlighted.] These are ads with no story or setup. They put the offer front and center. Now, we did our data collection between Black Friday and Christmas. > [VISUAL: On-screen graphic with two image carousels. Left is labeled "BLACK FRIDAY" and shows people shopping. Right is labeled "CHRISTMAS" and shows people with gifts and Christmas trees.] So hooks that signal immediacy and get straight to the point with a reason to act could actually be at an advantage with shoppers already in buy now mode. > [VISUAL: Text appears between the two image carousels: "AUDIENCES ARE IN BUY-NOW MODE"] Something that surprised me was how low bold claims and shocking statements were on the board. > [VISUAL: Screen recording of the "Spend use" table. The rows for "Shocking statement" and "Bold claim" are highlighted.] These are the hooks that I think of when I hear the word hook because they dominate my social feed. > [VISUAL: Three vertical videos play side-by-side, showing examples of social media content with bold claims.] This too could be influenced by the time of our data collection. But it could also be a sign of a dying trend. > [VISUAL: On-screen text overlays the speaker: "WHEN EVERY AD OPENS WITH THE SAME BOLD CLAIM IT'S NO LONGER THAT BOLD"] When every ad opens with the same bold claim, it's no longer that bold. It's no longer a good hook. It's a big flashing neon sign that says, "This is an ad trying to sell you something." > [VISUAL: A photo of a large neon sign on a building at night. The sign reads: "THIS IS AN AD TRYING TO SELL YOU SOMETHING".] And no one wants to be duped, let alone buy a fleeting social media trend. Contrast this with the success of urgency and FOMO hooks. > [VISUAL: Screen recording of the "Hit rate" table. The rows for "Urgency" and "FOMO" are highlighted.] While they're not as sexy as bold claims or shocking statements, they've been part of consumer psychology for decades. These are advertising fundamentals, not a trend that's going to spike and then tank just as fast. > [VISUAL: On-screen text overlays the speaker: "THESE ARE ADVERTISING FUNDAMENTALS NOT A TREND THAT'S GOING TO PASS"]

Now, ad types. > [VISUAL: A solid blue screen with white text: "THE TOP AD TYPES"] And this is where the data gets really counterintuitive because what looks like a winning ad and what actually gets spend are two very different things. High production videos, beautiful photography, fancy motion graphics. > [VISUAL: A montage of high-production ads: a car chase, a woman with a perfume bottle, and a soda can opening.] These seem like they should win, but in reality, text-only ads, product images with overlays, and gifts, they all lead to more winners. > [VISUAL: A montage of low-production ads: three phone screens showing static images with text overlays.] > [VISUAL: On-screen text: "THEY ALL LEAD TO MORE WINNERS."] Now, there's two reasons for that. First, they communicate value in under two seconds with no visual noise getting in the way of the message. This is similar to what we saw with top performing hooks. Second, because they're easy to make, you can test more creative faster. You can find out what's working sooner. Then make more and more iterations until you find a big winner. > [VISUAL: Screen recording of Adobe After Effects showing a project rendering.] All in the time that it takes to export something from After Effects. As we talked about in this video, Meta Ads is a numbers game. > [VISUAL: A graphic appears over the speaker's shoulder showing a YouTube thumbnail for a video titled "HOW MANY ADS DO YOU REALLY NEED?". The graphic then changes to a blue slide with text: "HOW META DISTRIBUTES YOUR AD BUDGET". It then changes to show a single ad leading to a dollar sign, which then leads to four smaller ads.] And in a system where winning is rare, you want to maximize your number of shots on target. This is why the volume of UGC ads absolutely dwarfs high production. > [VISUAL: A collage of user-generated content (UGC) ads appears and expands on screen.] High production ads can absolutely win. They just have a specific role. > [VISUAL: A high-production ad for a sunscreen stick is shown with on-screen text: "HI-FI ADS CAN STILL WIN THEY JUST PLAY A SPECIFIC ROLE"] Because they take longer to make, they're not built for discovery. Instead, you should use them to scale what's already proven. Maybe the quality and professionalism of a high production ad paired with that text-first message that always performs is actually the perfect combination for scale.

Now, let's look at the visual styles. > [VISUAL: A solid blue screen with white text: "TOP VISUAL STYLES"] This chart tells a more nuanced story, as you'll see the results are very different for hit rate and spend use. > [VISUAL: Screen recording of the Motion app webpage showing the "Visual format" table. The user toggles between the "Hit rate" and "Spend use" views.] For hit rate, unboxing led the way with nearly one in 10 ads becoming winners. > [VISUAL: The "Hit rate" table is shown. The row for "Unboxing" is highlighted.] Behind the scenes and founder ads ranked highly too, with both above 8%. > [VISUAL: The "Hit rate" table is shown. The row for "Founder" is highlighted.] But toggle over to spend use and the story changes. The top four visual styles here didn't even crack the top 25 for hit rate. > [VISUAL: The user toggles to the "Spend use" view. The top four rows are highlighted: "Celebrity", "Letter", "Unconventional text placement", and "Post it".] POV, which was among the highest hit rates, actually has the lowest ranking here for spend use ratio. > [VISUAL: The "Spend use" table is shown. The row for "POV" at the bottom of the list is highlighted.] So what does all this mean? > [VISUAL: On-screen text overlays the speaker: "WHAT DOES ALL THIS MEAN?"] First, the styles that rank well on both charts, offer-first banners, demos, these are your scale formats. > [VISUAL: Two phone screens appear. Left is labeled "Offer-first banners". Right is labeled "Demos".] Reliable, widely deployed, and trusted when performance matters. > [VISUAL: A bar chart with an upward arrow appears with the text "Scale Formats". Then, words appear one by one: "RELIABLE", "WIDELY DEPLOYED", "TRUSTED", "WHEN PERFORMANCE MATTERS".] If you're not running them, you're leaving money on the table. Second, when a style has a high hit rate and a low spend use ratio, like unboxing or POV, it means that while the style results in a lot of winners, the algorithm doesn't really keep scaling those the way that it does for other winning formats. > [VISUAL: Screen recording shows the "Hit rate" table with "Unboxing" and "POV" highlighted, then switches to the "Spend use" table where "Unboxing" is higher up and "POV" is at the bottom.] These ads win, but are quick to plateau. Lastly, ads with low hit rates and high spend use ratios, like celebrity ads, are your big swings. > [VISUAL: A phone screen showing a celebrity ad (Gordon Ramsay) appears next to text: "LOW HIT RATE + HIGH SPEND RATIO".] They don't account for a lot of winners, partially because they're so rare, but when they do win, they win big. The healthiest ad accounts will have a mix of all three of these.

So getting back to our main question, what ads are most likely to win? There are two takeaways. > [VISUAL: A solid purple screen with white text: "TAKEAWAY #1 PRIORITIZE MAKING LOW-EFFORT ADS THAT KEEP YOUR ACCOUNT RUNNING."] The more ads you make in a short period of time, the faster you can test. The faster you test, the quicker you can build off of those winning concepts. So, low-effort ads are your friend for keeping your ads machine running. But it's not just about speed. During windows like Black Friday and the holiday season, when audiences are typically in a buy now mode, you want to be harvesting, not planting. > [VISUAL: A graphic appears over the bookshelf. An arrow points from "PLANTING" to "HARVESTING". The speaker's hand draws a circle around "HARVESTING" and an X over "PLANTING".] That means you want to be prioritizing ads that get straight to the point where clarity beats being clever. In some cases, these end up being the same low-lift ads you should be doing anyways. > [VISUAL: Four phone screens appear, showing examples of low-effort, direct-to-the-point ads.] And just as we talked about, winning isn't everything. > [VISUAL: A solid purple screen with white text: "TAKEAWAY #2 WINNING ISN'T EVERYTHING."] There's a place in your ads account for reliable ads that don't really raise the roof, but they reinforce a high floor. It's not all hot takes and anecdotes either. Like this video, everything is backed by data, so you can see where you and your Meta account stand. If you want to go deeper into our research and get all of the specifics, check out our free 2026 Creative Benchmarks report at the link in the description. > [VISUAL: Screen recording of the Motion app "Creative Benchmarks 2026" report, scrolling through the text and charts.] We answered all the questions that creative strategists wonder at some point in their career, like how many ads do you actually need and how many ads should actually be winning? > [VISUAL: On-screen text appears: "HOW MANY ADS DO YOU ACTUALLY NEED?". It changes to: "HOW MANY ADS SHOULD BE WINNING?"] Check it out. And if you find that sort of information useful, give this video a like and subscribe to the channel. I'll see you in the next video.