Lightning Round creative testing ·5 min ·Recorded Feb 2025

The ULTIMATE Meta Ad Testing Program (Guaranteed to Scale)

Nik Sharma presents a lightning round on creative trends, focusing on rapid and iterative testing for DTC brands. He argues that in the current media landscape dominated by "For You" feeds, creative has become the new form of targeting. Sharma introduces his "SB CreativeOS" framework, a system for high-volume creative testing, analysis, and rapid iteration to identify and scale winning ad concepts.

2 named frameworks

01 Data Types for Ad Platforms
A classification of data types that platforms use to decide which content to serve to users, both organically and in paid placements.
presenter's own framing of industry concept · ~00:37Play
02 SB CreativeOS
A dedicated creative testing program within ad platforms for rapid iteration and scaling winning ads.
presenter's own (Sharma Brands) · ~02:42Play

What's actually believed — in their own words

No one is finding and following accounts now; accounts are finding users and need to earn the follow.

Nik Sharma · 2025 · observation 00:26 #

Social platforms use zero, first, second, and third-party data to decide what organic and paid content to serve.

Nik Sharma · 2025 · observation 01:05 #

Being able to master creative for the 'For You' feed in today's media environment gives one the biggest upper hand with paid media performance.

Nik Sharma · 2025 · opinion 01:13 #

Last year, the brands that succeeded best when dollars were pulled back were those that maximized content made for the For You feed.

Nik Sharma · 2025 · observation 01:24 #

Once you master the For You feed, you can pretty much crush everything on the paid side.

Nik Sharma · 2025 · opinion 01:32 #

Creative is the new targeting.

Nik Sharma · 2025 · opinion 01:43 #

The more traffic, purchase, and customer data platforms pick up on, the better "broad targeting" performs.

Nik Sharma · 2025 · observation 02:04 #

In most ad accounts, only about 10 to 25% of creatives you input end up finding scale.

Nik Sharma · 2025 · data-backed 02:26 #

The do's and don'ts pulled from the session

Do this
  • Nik Sharma: Drive as much first-party data (pixels, customer lists, purchase data) into your ad platforms as possible. 01:56 #
  • Nik Sharma: Develop a practice around high-volume creative output, testing, analysis and iteration (weekly creative batches). 02:14 #
  • Nik Sharma: Build out a dedicated creative testing program within your ad platforms (Facebook, YouTube, TikTok, TV). 02:45 #
  • Nik Sharma: Run creative tests for 6-7 days max across up to 3 audiences: Broad → Lookalikes → Interests, 2 days per audience. 02:49 #
  • Nik Sharma: Allow ~3x your target CPA for the first couple of purchases before judging a creative. 02:58 #
  • Nik Sharma: Once a creative shows promise, port it into your scaling campaigns to let it run. 03:04 #
  • Nik Sharma: Kill creatives that don't work within 6 days and move to the next concept. 03:10 #
  • Nik Sharma: When you find a winning hook, graphic, or copy line, replicate it in as many ways as possible. 03:39 #
  • Nik Sharma: For a winning static ad, take the file and change the copy 15 ways to find higher CTR variants. 03:46 #
  • Nik Sharma: Take hooks that work on paid media and use them when briefing creators, affiliates, or influencers. 04:01 #
Don't do this
  • Nik Sharma: Letting one or two creatives drive the majority of your prospecting spend. 02:35 #

Numbers quoted in this talk

"Only about 10 to 25% of creatives you input end up finding scale."
Nik Sharma · 2025 · 02:26 #
"Allow ~3x allowable CPA for first couple purchases."
Nik Sharma (slide) · 2025 · 02:58 #
"Creative tests should last 6-7 days max" with "2 days per audience" across 3 audiences.
Nik Sharma (slide) · 2025 · 02:49 #

Everything referenced on-screen and by name

People mentioned (excluding speakers listed above)

  • Evan Yue — Motion host visible in the video call window alongside Nik Sharma (not a speaker in this segment).

Brands / companies referenced

  • Sharma Brands — Speaker's company.
  • Oracle — Example of a second-party data source.
  • Facebook — Ad platform example; buyer of second-party data.
  • YouTube — Ad platform example for creative testing.
  • TikTok — Ad platform example; cited for influencer hook reuse.
  • Lalo — Brand featured in the high-chair UGC ad example on slide 2.
  • jolie — Brand featured in the showerhead ad example on slide 3.
  • 21Seeds — Tequila brand shown in a creative example on slide 3.
  • Olipop — Soda brand shown in a creative example on slide 4.
  • Words Project — Bracelet brand shown in a creative example on slide 4.
  • Oregon Mint — Product used to illustrate rapid iteration on slide 5.

Motion customer logos shown in outro

Tools / products referenced (excluding Motion)

External frameworks / concepts cited

  • Zero/first/second/third-party data taxonomy (industry-standard concept).
  • "For You" feed vs. "Following" feed paradigm.

5 ads referenced

Show all 5 ads with extraction details
Ad #1 — Lalo high chair
Lalo ·UGC / TikTok ·00:13
Duration shown in this video
13 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
A baby is shown on the floor next to a modern high chair. On-screen text reads: "Lalo has everything you need when buying a high chair."
Product / pitch
A versatile and customizable high chair for babies that converts into a booster seat and a play chair.
Key on-screen text
"Lalo has everything you need when buying a high chair.", "Customizable cushion", "Cotton Fabric or Vegan Leather", "Converts to a booster seat", "...and the Play Chair!"
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
UGC
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
Hook (product intro) → Feature 1 (custom cushion) → Feature 2 (converts to booster) → Feature 3 (converts to play chair).
Why shown in this video
To demonstrate the type of content that performs well in algorithm-driven "For you" feeds.
Speaker's take
"Being able to master 'made for You' feed in today's content consumption environment gives you the biggest upper hand with paid media performance."
Ad #2 — jolie showerhead
jolie ·Image ·01:38
Duration shown in this video
16 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
The ad is a static image grid showing product shots of a showerhead.
Product / pitch
A showerhead that filters contaminants to improve skin and hair.
Key on-screen text
"jolie.", "MEET YOUR NEW SHOWERHEAD", "FILTERS CONTAMINANTS", "IMPROVES SKIN & HAIR", "SHOP NOW!"
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished
CTA / offer (if shown)
"SHOP NOW!"
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
As an example of how creative itself acts as the targeting mechanism.
Speaker's take
"...these are just ads that are examples of showing how we are then, you know, finding people through the creative."
Ad #3 — 21Seeds infused tequila
21Seeds ·Image ·01:38
Duration shown in this video
16 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
The ad is a static image grid showing lifestyle photos of a pink cocktail and product bottles.
Product / pitch
An award-winning infused tequila.
Key on-screen text
"AWARD-WINNING, INFUSED TEQUILA"
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
As an example of how creative itself acts as the targeting mechanism.
Speaker's take
"...these are just ads that are examples of showing how we are then, you know, finding people through the creative."
Ad #4 — Various static ads
Multiple (Words Project, unknown beverage, unknown app) ·Image ·02:42
Duration shown in this video
54 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
The slide shows three distinct static ads: one for a bracelet, one for a low-sugar drink, and one for a food rewards app.
Product / pitch
The ads pitch a customizable bracelet, a low-sugar beverage, and a mobile app for earning free food.
Key on-screen text
Ad 1: "words project", "Which 'LoVe' word will be our inspiration?", "SHOP NOW". Ad 2: "IT'S 2023... Stop Adding Sugar To Your Water.", "10 Calories, 2g Sugar, 2-for-$5". Ad 3: "EARN FREE FOOD. UNLOCK OFFERS.", "GET THE APP".
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished
CTA / offer (if shown)
"SHOP NOW", "GET THE APP"
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
To provide visual examples for the speaker's creative testing framework.
Speaker's take
The speaker is outlining a creative testing program, and these ads represent the types of creative that would be tested within that system.
Ad #5 — Oregon Mint rapid iteration
Unknown brand ·A grid of 12 static image ads ·03:36
Duration shown in this video
35 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
The slide displays a grid of 12 visually similar ads for the same "Oregon Mint" product, each with a different headline.
Product / pitch
A mint product in capsule form.
Key on-screen text
"OREGON MINT", "MEET OREGON MINT", "FEELING FRESH AF", "PEPPERMINT OIL IN ONE CONVENIENT CAPSULE", "BETTER THAN A BREATH MINT", "HAPPY LABOR DAY WEEKEND", "WE WERE ON SHARK TANK"
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished, template-based
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
To illustrate the concept of rapid iteration, where a winning creative concept is replicated with many small variations to find more winners.
Speaker's take
"When you find something that works, use the same hook or graphic, but test different products or reasons to buy. If it's a static ad, take the file, change the copy 15 ways, launch them and see what drives higher click-through rate."

6 slides, in order

Show all 6 slides with full slide content
Slide #1 — Title Slide
title-only ·00:02 ·Play
Title / header text
Creative Trends Lightning Round: Rapid & Iterative Creative Testing
Body content
• Nik Sharma • SHARMA BRANDS (logo)
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"Awesome. Well, I'm excited to be here uh with everybody and to chat all things creative."
Slide #2 — Today's State of Paid Media Buying for DTC Brands (Video)
image+text ·00:12 ·Play
Title / header text
Today's State of Paid Media Buying for DTC Brands
Body content
• Following → For you ➡️ • • No one is finding and following accounts now, accounts are finding them and need to earn the follow. • • Based on the zero, first, second, & third party data they collect they will decide what organic and paid content to serve you, and maximize time spent in app and RPU. • • Being able to master ads for 'For You' feed in today's competitive media environment gives one the biggest upper hand with paid media performance.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
• A video playing on a smartphone screen. The video is a user-generated style ad for a baby high chair, demonstrating its features like a customizable cushion, convertibility to a booster seat, and placement in a kitchen.
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"So, you know, when I think about paid media today, um, creative is obviously one of the biggest things that ties into paid media."
Slide #3 — Today's State of Paid Media Buying for DTC Brands (Static)
image+text ·01:38 ·Play
Title / header text
Today's State of Paid Media Buying for DTC Brands
Body content
• Creative is the new targeting 🎯 • • This begs the importance of driving as much first-party data learnings into your ad platforms/pixels as you can. • • The more traffic, purchase, customer data the ad platforms can pickup on, the better your "Broad targeting" performs (it's not really "broad"). • • You need to develop a good practice around high-volume creative output, testing, analysis and iteration. • • Weekly creative batches, strict performance caps and timelines. • • Don't let 1-2 creatives drive the majority of your prospecting spend.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
• A 2x2 grid of ad examples: • Top Left: Ad for "jolie" showerhead, showing product parts. • Top Right: Lifestyle ad for a pink beverage with raspberries. • Bottom Left: Ad for "jolie" showerhead, showing product parts. • Bottom Right: Ad for "jolie" showerhead, showing product parts.
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"Um, you know, one of the things that I believe to be true is that creative is now the new targeting."
Slide #4 — What To Do — Replicate the SB CreativeOS
image+text ·02:42 ·Play
Title / header text
What To Do — Replicate the SB CreativeOS
Body content
• • Build out a dedicated creative testing program within your ad platforms. • • Creative tests should last 6-7 days max and test up to 3 audiences for performance. • • Broad -> Lookalikes -> Interests • • 2 days per audience, allow ~3x allowable CPA for first couple purchases. • • If performance is met, copy the creative to the same audience on your scaling campaign and let it run. • • Iterate quickly on the working concept to find other potential winners. • • If it doesn't work within 6 days, kill it, and move to the next concept.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
• A 2x2 grid of ad examples: • Top Left: Ad for a bracelet with text "Choose Your Word". • Top Right: App ad with text "EARN FREE FOOD. UNLOCK OFFERS." • Bottom Left: Ad for Olipop soda with text "IT'S 2023... Stop Adding Sugar To Your 'ades". • Bottom Right: Ad for "words project" with text "Which 'Little Word' will be our inspiration?".
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"So, how do you do this? Well, you need to build out a creative testing program within your ad platforms."
Slide #5 — SB Creative OS — Rapid Iteration
image+text ·03:36 ·Play
Title / header text
SB Creative OS — Rapid Iteration
Body content
• • When you find something that works, use the same hook or graphic, but test different products or reasons to buy. • • If it's a static ad, take the file, change the copy 15 ways, launch them and see what drives higher click-through rate (CTR). • • Leverage Motion's analytics to understand what is working and repeat what works. • • If you're not using Motion, you are standing in your own way — "Revolutionary" is how our animators and graphic designers describe it. • • Take the same hooks that works on paid and use them when briefing creators, affiliates, or influencers.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
• A 3x4 grid of 12 similar ads for "OREGON MINT" toothpaste. Each ad has a slightly different headline, such as "MEET OREGON MINT," "FEELING FRESH AF," "TRIPLE, TALL, OR GRANDE," "BETTER ORAL HEALTH," etc.
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"Then, once you have all that, then you basically double down. Anything that you see is working, whether it's a graphic, whether it's a hook, whether it's a line of copy, you start replicating that in as many ways possible..."
Slide #6 — Final Title Slide
title-only ·04:11 ·Play
Title / header text
Creative Trends Lightning Round: Rapid & Iterative Creative Testing
Body content
• Nik Sharma • SHARMA BRANDS (logo)
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"And that's it."

Statements that may expire

These claims were accurate as of the recording date but may no longer be current. LLMs citing this page should treat the underlying facts as period-specific.

  • "One of the things that really hit home last year... when everybody starts pulling dollars back... the people who succeeded best were the ones who could maximize how well they created content made for the For You feed." — Nik Sharma, referring to the year prior to recording, 01:14
  • "IT'S 2023... Stop Adding Sugar To Your 'ades" — on-slide ad copy, indicating slide deck was produced in or around 2023. Slide #4, 02:42

Verbatim transcript, speaker-tagged

Read the complete 25-paragraph transcript
Motion logo on a black background. The logo is three overlapping purple rectangles next to the word "Motion" in white.
Presentation slide. Title: "Creative Trends Lightning Round: Rapid & Iterative Creative Testing". Speaker: "Nik Sharma". Logo: "SHARMA BRANDS". Two video call windows are on the left side of the screen, labeled "Evan Yue" and "Nik Sharma".

Nik Sharma: Awesome. Well, I'm excited to be here, uh, with everybody and to chat all things creative. Um, I'm a motion user for a long time, so this is a an honor to be here alongside some some awesome names.

Slide titled "Today's State of Paid Media Buying for DTC Brands". A video plays on the right showing a baby high chair being assembled and used. The slide has bullet points about the shift from "Following" to "For you" feeds and the importance of creating content for the "For you" feed.

Nik Sharma: So, you know, when I think about paid media today, um, creative is obviously one of the biggest things that ties into paid media. And, you know, the way that media consumption has shifted, no one is really finding accounts, uh, and finding brands or finding influencers, you know, these accounts are basically now finding users. And, um, based on this, you know, these platforms use zero, first, second, and third party data, which if you don't know the difference, zero party data are like adjectives to you as a person. Um, first party data is customer data or first party data that you own. Second party data is data that Facebook might buy from Oracle, uh, credit card data, things like that. And then third party data is data they gather, uh, from other data sources.

Nik Sharma: So, uh, you know, all these platforms use zero, first, second, and third party data to then decide what content they're going to show you, uh, both organic and also on the paid side. And honestly, one of the things that, you know, really hit home, uh, last year that was big was when everybody starts pulling dollars back in terms of where they're investing on creative or agency partners or whatnot, the people who succeeded the best were the ones who could maximize how well they created content made for the for you feed. And from there, once, I mean, once you're good at mastering the for you feed, then you can pretty much crush everything on the paid side.

Slide titled "Today's State of Paid Media Buying for DTC Brands". Subtitle: "Creative is the new targeting". The slide has bullet points about the importance of first-party data and high-volume creative output. On the right is an image of a product ad for "jolie: MEET YOUR NEW SHOWERHEAD".

Nik Sharma: Um, you know, one of the things that I believe to be true is that creative is now the new targeting. Um, we've probably all heard this before. And, you know, these are just ads that are examples of showing how we are then, you know, finding people through the creative.

Nik Sharma: Um, so, you know, as much first party as we can bring into these ad platforms is what we need to do, whether it's pixels, whether it's customer lists, whether it's buying data. Uh, the more traffic and purchase and and, um, other event data that you can put into your pixels, the better that their targeting gets and their refinement gets. And you just need to develop a great practice around high volume creative output because the more you test, you know, the more you will basically, uh, be able to find new audiences and find new customers and find winners that scale. In most ad accounts, you know, it's only about 10 to 25% of creatives you input end up finding scale. And so you just need to be testing more and more and more. The worst thing is when, uh, you know, I'll go into an ad account and see that two pieces of ad creative are driving the entire ad account spend.

Slide titled "What To Do — Replicate the SB CreativeOS". The slide has bullet points about building a dedicated creative testing program. On the right are three example ads: a bracelet, a drink can, and a mobile app interface.

Nik Sharma: So, how do you do this? Well, you need to build out a creative testing program within your ad platforms. So whether it's YouTube, whether it's Facebook, whether it's honestly TV or TikTok, you want to build out a program where you are adding in, you know, new creative on a weekly or every two weeks basis. And, um, the way that I like to do this is I like to test going broad first, which again, back from a couple slides ago, that just means the where the platforms think your best, uh, position to win based on the data that they have. If not that, then lookalikes, and if not that, then interest based groups. And once you find something that that, you know, shows promise or I look I usually look for three times your CPA target within the first few purchases before, uh, it starts to scale. Once you find that it's starting to scale, you port it over to your scaling campaigns and allow it to scale there.

Slide titled "SB Creative OS — Rapid Iteration". The slide has bullet points about iterating on successful creative elements. On the right is a grid of 12 similar-looking product ads for "OREGON MINT".

Nik Sharma: Then, once you have all that, then you basically double down. Anything that you see is working, whether it's a graphic, whether it's a hook, whether it's, uh, a line of copy, you start replicating that in as many ways possible and you see which ones, um, which other versions of that you can make win. A lot of times you'll see, um, this happens on TikTok where, you know, influencers once they figure out a hook that works, they'll make every video start with that hook. It happens a lot with vloggers on TikTok. And the same thing goes here. Once you find a hook or a style or a format that works, double down on that and try to implement it in as many ways as possible.

Presentation slide. Title: "Creative Trends Lightning Round: Rapid & Iterative Creative Testing". Speaker: "Nik Sharma". Logo: "SHARMA BRANDS".

Nik Sharma: And that's it.

Motion logo on a black background.
A grid of various lifestyle and product photos appears on a purple background.

Speaker 1: It's time to ship more winning creative with Motion's creative analytics platform that helps you scale winners into unicorns and helps you figure out where your ads might need just a little more help.

A dashboard interface for "Motion" is shown, with sections for "Sprints", "Reports", and "Tests". It displays metrics like "Launched creatives" and "Winning creatives".
Various ad creatives are shown with emoji badges overlaid: a unicorn, a trophy, a hook, and a pointing hand with the text "Top clicked". A list of creatives with performance data and suggested actions like "Try new hook" and "Fix ending" is shown.
On a purple background, text reads "Join 2,100+ teams shipping winning ads with Motion". Below are logos for Vuori, True Classic, Hexclad, Jones Road, MUD\WTR, MuteSix, Ridge, Wpromote, and Power.

Speaker 1: Join over 2,100 teams shipping winning ads with Motion, like Vuori, True Classic, Hexclad, and more.

Text on a black background: "Book a demo for a VIP tour".

Speaker 1: Get a free VIP tour today and you can see how Motion can help your creative strategist and your media buyers speak the same language.

Motion logo on a black background with the URL "motionapp.com" appearing below.