Product Demo creative fatigue ·4 min ·Recorded Jan 2024

Keep an Eye on Creative Fatigue

This video is a tutorial on using the Motion platform to build a creative fatigue report. The speaker demonstrates creating a "Top performing" report with a line chart view, selecting CPC and Spend as lead metrics, applying color formatting and a spend filter to isolate high-spending creatives, and analyzing trends over time. The speaker also advises checking ROAS before pausing a fatiguing ad and proactively creating iterations of top spenders to maintain account performance.

What's discussed, in order

What's actually believed — in their own words

Creative fatigue in top-spending ads can affect overall account performance.

Speaker 1 · 2024 · observation 00:09 #

CPC is a strong lead metric for indicating creative fatigue because rising CPC acts as a red flag.

Speaker 1 · 2024 · opinion 00:45 #

Red/green color formatting in the table quickly reveals which ads are above and below average.

Speaker 1 · 2024 · observation 01:04 #

Filtering for spend thresholds ensures analysis focuses on high-impact creatives.

Speaker 1 · 2024 · opinion 01:33 #

An increasing CPC doesn't necessarily mean an ad should be paused.

Speaker 1 · 2024 · opinion 03:03 #

A fatiguing ad with strong ROAS can be kept running while monitored closely.

Speaker 1 · 2024 · opinion 03:20 #

When a top-spending ad begins to fatigue, creating iterations (e.g., new hooks) produces replacement winners.

Speaker 1 · 2024 · opinion 03:27 #

The demo account has limited data, which restricts the visible trends in the example.

Speaker 1 · 2024 · observation 02:30 #

The do's and don'ts pulled from the session

Do this
  • Speaker 1: Build a "Top performing" report in Motion to monitor creative fatigue. 00:22 #
  • Speaker 1: Switch to line chart view to visualize performance trends over time. 00:26 #
  • Speaker 1: Apply red/green color formatting in table settings to spot below-average performers. 01:03 #
  • Speaker 1: Sort by CPC (highest first) to surface the most expensive, potentially fatiguing ads. 01:16 #
  • Speaker 1: Add a spend filter (e.g., >$1,000, adjustable to $100/$1K/$10K based on account) to focus on meaningful creatives. 01:34 #
  • Speaker 1: Select individual ads via checkbox to plot their performance on the line chart. 01:24 #
  • Speaker 1: Also sort by Spend to identify your biggest spenders for analysis. 02:45 #
  • Speaker 1: Swap the Spend metric for ROAS to check whether a fatiguing ad is still profitable. 03:11 #
  • Speaker 1: When a top spender starts fatiguing, create iterations — e.g., change the hook or capture the same essence in a secondary ad. 03:27 #
Don't do this
  • Speaker 1: Don't automatically pause or turn off an ad just because CPC is rising — check ROAS first. 03:03 #

Everything referenced on-screen and by name

People mentioned (excluding speakers listed above)

Brands / companies referenced

  • Motion (Motion Plus One interface shown)

Tools / products referenced (excluding Motion)

External frameworks / concepts cited

  • CPC (Cost Per Click)
  • ROAS (Return On Ad Spend)
  • Creative fatigue

5 ads referenced

Show all 5 ads with extraction details
Ad #1 — Lavender home fragrance
Unknown brand ·Image ·00:04
Duration shown in this video
3 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
Not applicable (static thumbnail shown).
Product / pitch
A lavender-scented home fragrance product, possibly a candle or diffuser.
Key on-screen text
None used
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
Shown as one of many examples in a dashboard to demonstrate how to build a creative fatigue report.
Speaker's take
The speaker does not comment on this specific ad, but uses the collection of ads to illustrate the software's features for tracking performance metrics like CPC and Spend over time.
Ad #2 — Kitchen stink remover
Unknown brand ·Video ·00:04
Duration shown in this video
3 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
Not applicable (static thumbnail shown).
Product / pitch
A product designed to eliminate kitchen odors, with the thumbnail showing it in a bathroom setting.
Key on-screen text
None used
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
Shown as one of many examples in a dashboard to demonstrate how to build a creative fatigue report.
Speaker's take
The speaker does not comment on this specific ad, but uses the collection of ads to illustrate the software's features for tracking performance metrics like CPC and Spend over time.
Ad #3 — Colorful pixelated gift image
Unknown brand ·Image ·00:04
Duration shown in this video
3 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
Not applicable (static thumbnail shown).
Product / pitch
A gift item, as indicated by the ad's file name in the dashboard ("Gifts_Image_50OFF_HP_Megatron").
Key on-screen text
None used
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Animated
CTA / offer (if shown)
The ad's file name suggests a "50% OFF" offer.
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
Shown as one of many examples in a dashboard to demonstrate how to build a creative fatigue report.
Speaker's take
The speaker does not comment on this specific ad, but uses the collection of ads to illustrate the software's features for tracking performance metrics like CPC and Spend over time.
Ad #4 — Gift Carousel BOGO
Unknown brand ·Carousel ·01:06
Duration shown in this video
5 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
Not applicable (static thumbnail shown).
Product / pitch
A gift item, likely a candle, based on the thumbnail showing a candle in a box.
Key on-screen text
None used
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished
CTA / offer (if shown)
The ad's file name ("Gifts_Carousel_BOGO_LP_Wheelja...") suggests a "BOGO" (Buy One, Get One) offer.
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
This ad is specifically selected by the speaker to demonstrate how to analyze a single ad's performance over time in the line chart.
Speaker's take
"I'm going to select just my top one here to pull into this chart... Now I can start to take a look at what's happening."
Ad #5 — Lavender hallways video
Unknown brand ·Video ·02:49
Duration shown in this video
6 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
Not applicable (static thumbnail shown).
Product / pitch
A lavender-scented product, likely a candle, for home fragrance.
Key on-screen text
None used
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
This ad is specifically selected by the speaker as an example of a high-spending creative ($6,000+ spend) to analyze for fatigue.
Speaker's take
"I might say like, oh, okay, this one spent, um, $6,000. I want to pull that one in and analyze that to see what's happening."

8 slides, in order

Show all 8 slides with full slide content
Slide #1 — Title Card
title-only ·00:00 ·Play
Title / header text
OUR FAVORITE ANALYSES
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
State 1 (00:00)
Title "OUR FAVORITE ANALYSES" is visible.
State 2 (00:01)
Logo "Motion" and subtitle "Keep an eye on creative fatigue" appear.
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
None used
Slide #2 — Motion Report UI: Bar Chart View
screenshot-with-annotations ·00:04 ·Play
Title / header text
Untitled
Body content
Sidebar Menu
• Folders • Reports • Top Creatives • Image Iteration • Video Iteration (3sec) • Video Iteration (Creative v...) • Creative Team • Which offer works better? %... • Concept Comparison • High Converting Creatives • Lead Generating Creatives • Creative Format Comparison • Audience Comparison • Landing Page Comparison • Stage of Funnel • Creative Fatigue • BFCM 23 Recap • BFCM 22 Adset
Embedded data (charts/tables)
Report Filters
Last 14 days Dec 1 - 14, 2023 | Group by Ad Name
Metrics
CPC (link click) | Spend
Chart
Bar Chart
Y-axis (Left)
CPC (link click) from $0 to $0.60
Y-axis (Right)
Spend from $0 to $2.4k
X-axis
Ad creative thumbnails.
Table
Columns
(Checkbox), Thumbnail, Ad Name, Tags, Spend, ROAS, CPA, CPM, Thumbstop
Row 1
Gifts_Image_50OFF_HP_Megatron, $216.22, 6.23, $7.72, $10.09, 0.00%
Embedded examples
• Multiple ad creative thumbnails are shown, including "Lavender hal...", "Gifts_Carous...", "Remove the...".
Annotations / visual emphasis
• The speaker's face is visible in a circular video overlay in the bottom left.
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"Let's talk creative fatigue. Creative fatigue is super important to keep an eye on."
Slide #3 — Motion Report UI: Line Chart View
screenshot-with-annotations ·00:26 ·Play
Title / header text
Untitled
Body content
Same as previous slide.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
Report Filters
Last 14 days Dec 1 - 14, 2023 | Group by Ad Name
Metrics
CPC (link click) | Spend
Chart
Line Chart
Y-axis (Left)
CPC (link click) from $0.20 to $0.80
Y-axis (Right)
Spend from $62.22 to $248.89
X-axis
Dates from Dec 1 to Dec 13. • Multiple colored lines representing different ad creatives.
Table
Same as previous slide.
Embedded examples
Same as previous slide.
Annotations / visual emphasis
• The "Daily" and "Line Chart" icons are implicitly highlighted as the view has changed.
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"I'm going to swap over to line chart view. Line chart view is going to show me over a period of time how things are changing."
Slide #4 — Motion Report UI: Color-Coded Table
screenshot-with-annotations ·01:03 ·Play
Title / header text
Untitled
Body content
Same as previous slide.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
Chart
Line Chart (as before).
Table
Now has color-coded cells (red for below average, green for above average).
Columns
(Checkbox), Thumbnail, Ad Name, Tags, Spend, ROAS, CPA, CPM, Thumbstop, CTR (outbound), Click to purchase, ADV, CPC (link click)
Example Row
Lavender hallways_Image_NEW_H..., Sprint 3, $364.65, 2.77 (red), $13.02 (red), $11.29 (red), 0.00% (green), 1.91% (green), 3.03% (red)
Embedded examples
Same as previous slide.
Annotations / visual emphasis
• The table cells are now a heatmap of red and green. • The "Table settings" dropdown is shown, with the red/green color formatting option selected.
Re-reference
01:16
The table is sorted by the "CPC (link click)" column, from highest cost to lowest.
Speaker's framing
"I'm going to put it to this red and green... that's going to quickly give me a glance of all my ads pulling into this report, which ones are above and below average."
Slide #5 — Motion Report UI: Single Ad Analysis
screenshot-with-annotations ·01:24 ·Play
Title / header text
Untitled
Body content
Same as previous slide.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
Chart
Line Chart, now filtered to show only one ad.
Solid Line
CPC (link click)
Dashed Line
Spend
Table
The first ad ("Gifts_Carousel_BOGO_LP_Wheeljack") is selected with a checkbox.
Embedded examples
Same as previous slide.
Annotations / visual emphasis
01:27
A tooltip appears on the chart for Dec 7, showing: • Gifts_Carousel_BOGO_LP_Wheeljack • CPC (link click): $0.83 • Spend: $89.90
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"And I'm going to select just my top one here to pull into this chart."
Slide #6 — Motion Report UI: Adding a Spend Filter
screenshot-with-annotations ·01:34 ·Play
Title / header text
Untitled
Body content
• A filter creation modal is overlaid on the report.
Modal Content
• Search bar • Filter by: Campaign name, Ad set name, Ad name, Ad setup, Tags, Performance metrics
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
• The "Add filter" button is clicked. • "Performance metrics" is selected, then "Spend". • A condition builder appears: "Where Spend > 1000 USD".
Re-reference
01:41
The filter is applied, and a "Spend > $1,000" tag appears next to the "Group by" dropdown. The chart and table data update.
Speaker's framing
"So you're probably going to want to add a filter for spend. I'm going to put spend above a thousand dollars in my case."
Slide #7 — Motion Report UI: Analyzing a High-Spend Ad
screenshot-with-annotations ·02:52 ·Play
Title / header text
Untitled
Body content
Same as previous slides.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
Filter
Spend > $1,000
Chart
Line Chart, filtered to show the ad "Lavender hallways_Video_NEW_LP_Optimus Prime".
Solid Line
CPC (link click)
Dashed Line
Spend
Table
The ad "Lavender hallways_Video_NEW_LP..." is selected. This ad has a spend of $6,343.06.
Embedded examples
Same as previous slides.
Annotations / visual emphasis
02:55
A tooltip appears on the chart for Dec 2, showing: • CPC (link click): $0.58 • Spend: $422.76
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"I might say like, oh, okay, this one spent $6,000. I want to pull that one in and analyze that to see what's happening."
Slide #8 — Motion Report UI: Analyzing CPC vs. ROAS
screenshot-with-annotations ·03:15 ·Play
Title / header text
Untitled
Body content
Same as previous slides.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
Filter
Spend > $1,000
Metrics
CPC (link click) | ROAS
Chart
Line Chart, showing the same ad as the previous slide.
Solid Line
CPC (link click)
Dashed Line
ROAS
Y-axis (Left)
CPC (link click) from $0.20 to $0.80
Y-axis (Right)
ROAS from 2.50 to 5.50
Embedded examples
Same as previous slides.
Annotations / visual emphasis
• The "Spend" metric has been replaced with "ROAS".
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"Something I like to do as well is take a look at ROAS. So we could throw in ROAS instead here and just see what's happening with that."

Verbatim transcript, speaker-tagged

Read the complete 40-paragraph transcript

Speaker 1: Let's talk creative fatigue.

A title card with a purple background and the Motion logo. Text reads: "OUR FAVORITE ANALYSES" and "Keep an eye on creative fatigue".
The screen changes to the Motion Plus One software interface. A woman appears in a circular video feed in the bottom left. The main screen shows a bar chart report titled "Untitled".

Speaker 1: Creative fatigue is super important to keep an eye on because if we do have some top spenders within our account that is starting to hit fatigue, this can affect your overall account performance. So let's go ahead and build a creative fatigue report in Motion.

The speaker's cursor moves to the top left of the interface.

Speaker 1: To do that, go ahead and click create report up in the top left hand menu and we're going to build a top performing report.

The cursor clicks "Create report". A dropdown menu appears with "Top performing" and "Comparative analysis". The cursor clicks "Top performing".

Speaker 1: Once you're in here, I'm going to swap over to line chart view.

The cursor moves to the top right of the chart area and clicks the line chart icon. The bar chart changes to a line chart.

Speaker 1: Line chart view is going to show me over a period of time how things are changing. So it's a really great way to see if I'm noticing any trends of that line increasing, like I mentioned for creative fatigue. Now, to keep an eye on that, the metrics I like to pull in here is CPC and spend.

The metrics selected above the chart are "CPC (link click)" and "Spend".

Speaker 1: The reason I like to use CPC as the lead metric here in terms of indicating fatigue is because if that cost is increasing, that's essentially a red flag alert of, ooh, okay, this ad's most likely starting to fatigue. So once you've gone ahead and added those metrics, the next things you're going to want to do is adjust your table settings.

The speaker scrolls down to the table below the chart. The cursor clicks on "Table settings".

Speaker 1: I'm going to put it to this red and green.

In the "Table settings" dropdown, the cursor clicks on the "Color formatting" option with red and green squares. The cells in the table below are now colored red or green.

Speaker 1: That's going to quickly give me a glance of all my ads pulling into this report, which ones are above and below average. So I want to see specifically that CPC, the ones that are hitting that red mark of below average. I'm going to organize by my lowest CPC first, or the highest cost CPC, I guess is the better way to say it.

The speaker scrolls the table to the right to the "CPC (link of T4)" column. She clicks the column header to sort it, showing the highest CPCs at the top.

Speaker 1: And I'm going to select just my top one here to pull into this chart.

The speaker clicks the checkbox next to the first ad in the sorted list. The line chart above updates to show only the data for that one ad.

Speaker 1: Now, another thing you're most likely going to want to do before you start analyzing ones that are possibly hitting some creative fatigue, is you're probably going to want to add a filter for spend.

The speaker's cursor moves to the top of the report and clicks "Add filter".

Speaker 1: I'm going to put spend above a thousand dollars in my case.

A dropdown appears. The cursor selects "Performance metrics," then "Spend." A modal appears. The speaker types "1000" into the box and clicks "Apply".

Speaker 1: I want to make sure I'm looking at some of my high spender ads. Feel free to adjust this number to whatever makes the most sense to you. Might be a hundred dollars, might be this thousand, might be 10,000, whatever it might be, feel free to throw a filter on for spend above so we're only looking at some of our really high performing ads. Once you've done that, now it's going to pull in all my ads that are meeting that criteria of being at least a thousand dollars spend or more.

The report reloads with the filter applied. The table now shows a list of ads that have spent over $1,000.

Speaker 1: So now I'm going to take a look at, and I think we should still have it organized by CPC. Yep.

The speaker scrolls the table to the right, confirming the CPC column is still sorted from highest to lowest.

Speaker 1: I'm going to pull in this top ad just to start.

The speaker clicks the checkbox for the first ad in the list. The line chart updates.

Speaker 1: Now I can start to take a look at what's happening. If I click on this line here, it's going to show me both lines.

The speaker hovers over the line chart, and a tooltip appears showing CPC and Spend for a specific date. She then clicks on the line itself.

Speaker 1: So your solid line is that first metric, dotted line is the second metric. So I like to pull spend in here just to see what's happening with spend as well too. But essentially, and because this is our demo account, we're a little bit lacking in terms of the data pulling in here, but hopefully you'll start to see some trends of that CPC increasing or CPC staying very consistent. And that's going to again, just help to show you if an ad is hitting that fatigue. Now, another thing I might do is take a peek through here and take a look at what truly some of my biggest spenders are.

The speaker unchecks the selected ad. She scrolls down the table and sorts by the "Spend" column.

Speaker 1: So I might say like, oh, okay, this one spent um, $6,000. I want to pull that one in and analyze that to see what's happening.

The speaker finds an ad with over $6,000 in spend and clicks its checkbox. The line chart updates.

Speaker 1: Click on the line and there we go. I can start to compare these two metrics to see if I'm noticing any trends here.

The line chart now shows a solid line for CPC and a dashed line for Spend for the high-spending ad.

Speaker 1: Now, even if I see that CPC is starting to increase on some of my ads, it doesn't necessarily mean we should turn it off or pause it. Some things I like to do as well is take a look at ROAS. So we could throw in ROAS instead here.

The speaker clicks the "x" to remove the "Spend" metric. She then clicks "Add metric," types "roas," and selects "ROAS" from the list.

Speaker 1: And just see what's happening with that. Are we still getting a really good return on it? If so, we might just keep it running. We just might want to keep a close eye on it if we know that it's an ad that's starting to hit that fatigue. And the next thing you might want to do is think about some iteration opportunities. If you know this is a really big spender within the account and it's an ad that has been working really well for us in the past, maybe we want to start exploring some opportunities to make iterations of this ad. So can we maybe change up the hook? Can we try to pull the same essence of this ad and create a secondary ad? Start running these now that we know that this one's starting to hit fatigue. So hopefully we can start to get some additional winners within those different iterations. That way if we do have to pause or turn off this ad, we've got some great winners that are ready for us and that can continue to keep the account running and keep it in a really good state.