Tutorial creative production ·52 min ·Recorded Sep 2024

How To Build The BEST Performance Marketing Team EVER

Shahbaz Khokhar, CEO of Venture Beyond, presents a detailed framework for scaling creative output to launch 1,000+ performance creatives per month per brand. He breaks down the team structure (Pod Team + Delivery Teams), sprint planning process, ad lifecycle workflow (Ideas → Briefing → Editing → Approvals → Launch → Conclude), and KPIs/SLAs his agency uses. The presentation emphasizes systematic processes, reducing communication bottlenecks, empowering delivery teams with open briefs, and leveraging a custom-built WorkOS called Ad Sprint to manage production at scale.

What's discussed, in order

10 named frameworks

01 Revenue Growth Formula
A simple formula to conceptualize the drivers of revenue growth from advertising.
presenter's own · ~04:51Play
02 Ad Quality Metric
An internal metric to quantify the success rate of ads launched.
presenter's own · ~05:03Play
03 Ad Quantity Formula
A formula to calculate the potential ad output of a team.
presenter's own · ~05:38Play
04 Venture Beyond Team Structure [Before] (Hub-and-Spoke)
Previous team structure where a central Pod Team acted as a bottleneck hub for all specialized teams.
presenter's own · ~11:21Play
05 Venture Beyond Team Structure [After] (Cluster Model)
Current team structure where a small strategic Pod gives high-level direction to empowered Delivery Teams that originate their own work.
presenter's own · ~15:09Play
06 Communication Lines Formula
Formula showing exponential growth of communication overhead with team size.
Google (cited by speaker) · ~12:51Play
07 Creative Production Equilibrium (Pick 2)
Trade-off triangle for creative production.
presenter's own · ~17:49Play
08 Ad Lifecycle Workflow (6 Stages)
Systematic step-by-step process for producing ads at scale.
presenter's own · ~27:32Play
09 Open/Closed Brief Tiers
A tiered brief system allowing different levels of creative freedom for editors.
presenter's own · ~36:34Play
10 Muri, Mura, Muda (applied to creative ops)
Japanese manufacturing principle applied to resource forecasting: eliminate overburden, unevenness, and waste.
Toyota Production System (cited) · ~35:47Play

What's actually believed — in their own words

More ads launched correlates strongly with more ad spend (and revenue).

Shahbaz Khokhar · 2024 · data-backed 01:25 #

Volume is the primary lever for scale; scaling is a volume game.

Shahbaz Khokhar · 2024 · opinion 03:11 #

A 3-person pod can crack $1M in monthly ad spend.

Shahbaz Khokhar · 2024 · anecdote 10:56 #

A team of 40 generates 1,560 theoretical lines of communication.

Shahbaz Khokhar · 2024 · data-backed 12:51 #

You cannot simultaneously achieve high volume, low cost, and high quality — pick two.

Shahbaz Khokhar · 2024 · opinion 17:57 #

Typical ad success ratio (ads spending >$1,000 in 7 days) is around 5%.

Shahbaz Khokhar · 2024 · data-backed 05:28 #

The impact of creative work is deferred — ads launched one month drive significant spend in following months.

Shahbaz Khokhar · 2024 · data-backed 25:24 #

Speed of execution is a prerequisite for success in performance creative.

Shahbaz Khokhar · 2024 · opinion 26:39 #

Sometimes the sprint plan needs to be broken in exchange for data insights (unplanned work is valuable).

Shahbaz Khokhar · 2024 · opinion 24:08 #

Venture Beyond headcount has not materially increased in 18 months because they focused on efficiency gains instead.

Shahbaz Khokhar · 2024 · anecdote 19:52 #

A central Pod Team acting as a hub creates bottlenecks and underutilizes specialized sub-teams.

Shahbaz Khokhar · 2024 · observation 12:14 #

The do's and don'ts pulled from the session

Do this
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Work backwards from current team resource to determine brief volume, not forwards from ideal targets. 18:41 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Plan in 1-week or 2-week sprints. 18:48 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Increase efficiency (quality × quantity) before adding headcount. 19:48 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Maintain strong asset management (one dedicated person reorganizing folders) so old assets keep getting reused. 20:19 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Force editors to upload project files so iterations are one-click rebriefs. 20:40 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Geographical arbitrage — UK lead editors for real-time CS collaboration, remote editors for heavy iterative work. 20:51 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Implement time tracking to reduce remote editor downtime. 21:23 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Allow editors to write their own Open Briefs rather than waiting for creative strategists. 21:40 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Use AI tools: RunwayML + Photoshop to video-ize winning statics; Eleven Labs for voiceover testing; Arcads for AI avatars; Heygen for translation; Midjourney/FLUX Realism LORA for image generation. 22:00 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Use a tiered brief system (Open/Semi-Open/Closed) matched to editor seniority. 36:34 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Implement automated ad naming conventions driven by spreadsheet columns. 35:10 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Set an internal 7-day SLA for creative production from brief to launch. 40:44 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Use WhatsApp groups with an internal assistant to communicate with content creators at speed, while extracting briefs into formal systems. 51:20 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Display daily data dashboards on office TVs (powered by Raspberry Pi + Looker Studio + Supermetrics) for team visibility. 40:00 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Push clients toward daily (not 1-2×/week) approval cadences. 42:41 #
Don't do this
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: "Spray and pray" — producing creative without a systematic process or hypothesis. 27:14 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Adding headcount before fixing process inefficiencies. 19:48 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Routing every brief and approval through a single central Pod Team. 12:14 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Continuing to work with unreliable content creators who miss deadlines or deliver poor work. 50:02 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Accepting client approval cadences of only 1–2 times per week. 42:41 #
  • Shahbaz Khokhar: Treating all three corners of the Volume/Cost/Quality triangle as achievable simultaneously. 17:57 #

Numbers quoted in this talk

**$4,116,018.49** ad spend in 30 days (26 Dec 2022 – 24 Jan 2023) for one client
Shahbaz Khokhar · 2024 · 00:36 #
**62,909** website purchases in that period — slide,
2024 · 00:36 #
**$6,330,787.67** website purchase conversion value — slide,
2024 · 00:36 #
**$22.07** CPM; **186,461,876** impressions — slide,
2024 · 00:36 #
**750 ads/month** at **$4.1M** monthly spend for one brand —
2024 · 01:55 #
**429 ads/month** at peak **$2.2M** monthly spend for another account —
2024 · 02:18 #
**35,159** raw video & image assets produced → **5,151** ads produced (year) — 02:39–02:55
2024 · #
**2,544** new concept ads / **2,607** iteration ads (near-even split) —
2024 · 03:02 #
Ad quality success ratio **~5%** —
2024 · 05:28 #
Team of **40** = **1,560** lines of communication —
2024 · 12:51 #
Planned vs Unplanned ad sets: **233 planned / 110 unplanned** over ~1,800 ads sample —
2024 · 24:02 #
Deferred impact cohort (ads launched Jan 2024): **29.2%** of Jan spend, **38.4%** of Feb spend, **22.2%** of Mar spend, **10.8%** of Apr spend —
2024 · 25:36 #
Creative production SLA: **7 days** brief-to-launch —
2024 · 40:44 #
Minimum spend for agency engagement: **$100k/month** —
2024 · 44:51 #
Agency ad account cashback: **5%** (i.e., $50k back per $1M spent) —
2024 · 45:05 #

Everything referenced on-screen and by name

People mentioned (excluding speakers listed above)

  • Elon Musk — Meme/cited humorously to illustrate the impulse to want maximum ad volume
  • Jem — Event producer/moderator, referenced by speaker asking about chat
  • Cam Verghese — Appears in webcam tile at opening (host/co-host); not a primary speaker
  • Dima Vityukov — Audience member (questions in chat re: triangle, creator sourcing)
  • Alex — Audience member (recruiting question)
  • JL — Audience member (question on unreliable creators)

Brands / companies referenced

  • Venture Beyond (speaker's agency) —
  • Meta
  • Client brands shown: Delsey, Benetton, Jeep, Peugeot, Timio, Naked & Thriving, Cheflix, Larsson & Jennings, Kallistia, Mindful Modern, Lava Art, Ooni, Forge & Foster, Insculpure, BiOptimizers, Fit AF TV, Winona
  • Freddie — laundry detergent sheets brand shown in ad example —

Tools / products referenced (excluding Motion)

  • Midjourney
  • Canva
  • Frame.io
  • RunwayML
  • Photoshop / Generative Fill
  • Eleven Labs
  • Arcads
  • Heygen
  • FLUX Realism LORA
  • Monday.com — outgrown ("We broke Monday.com")
  • Asana, ClickUp — mentioned as alternatives
  • PageProof
  • Supermetrics
  • Looker Studio
  • Raspberry Pi — powers office dashboard TVs
  • Insense, Billo — content creator sourcing platforms
  • Ad Sprint / AdSprint.ai — speaker's own custom WorkOS (29:17, early access at 44:18)

External frameworks / concepts cited

  • Muri, Mura, Muda — Toyota Production System / Japanese manufacturing principle
  • Google communication-lines diagram

11 ads referenced

Show all 11 ads with extraction details
Ad #1 — Delsey Suitcase (Static)
Delsey ·Image ·29:48
Duration shown in this video
5 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
A static image of a grey hardshell suitcase.
Product / pitch
A hardshell suitcase.
Key on-screen text
3010x - Product Benefits Static
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
To show an example of a creative being managed within the speaker's custom-built project management software, "Ad Sprint".
Speaker's take
"You can see everything that we're doing for that client."
Ad #2 — Delsey Suitcase (Video)
Delsey ·Video ·29:48
Duration shown in this video
5 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
A video showing a red hardshell suitcase.
Product / pitch
A hardshell suitcase.
Key on-screen text
3087x - KSMV with the suitcase
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
To show an example of a creative being managed within the speaker's custom-built project management software, "Ad Sprint".
Speaker's take
"You can see everything that we're doing for that client."
Ad #3 — Jeep Branded Video
Jeep ·Video ·30:24
Duration shown in this video
3 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
A video featuring the Jeep logo.
Product / pitch
Jeep branded products.
Key on-screen text
Jeep
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
To show an example of a creative in the "Backlog" stage of the workflow.
Speaker's take
"Things start in the backlog, so this is like where the ideas get captured."
Ad #4 — Laundry Detergent Sheets
Freddie ·Video (TikTok style) ·31:03
Duration shown in this video
3 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
A TikTok-style video showing a pink cat-shaped plush toy being squeezed, with a text overlay.
Product / pitch
Laundry detergent sheets.
Key on-screen text
EXPOSED: Why popular LAUNDRY Detergent Sheets aren't worth it
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
UGC
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
To show an example of an "inspiration file" and a brief in their system.
Speaker's take
"This is a live brief... we have some instructions for an editor... we have the script... we have the storyboard."
Ad #5 — Hyaluronic Acid Serums
Naked and Thriving ·Image ·32:58
Duration shown in this video
5 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
A split-screen image comparing two red bottles of serum.
Product / pitch
Hyaluronic acid serums for skin.
Key on-screen text
We Compared Two Popular Hyaluronic Acid Serums To See Which One Is Best For Skin
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
To show an example of a creative in the "Edit" stage of their workflow.
Speaker's take
"Once it's been briefed it goes to edit."
Ad #6 — Osmotic Eyes
Skkn (implied) ·Image ·32:58
Duration shown in this video
5 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
A close-up image of a woman's eye with a text overlay.
Product / pitch
An eye cream for "osmotic eyes".
Key on-screen text
Are You Struggling With Osmotic Eyes? TRY THIS.
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
To show an example of a creative in the "Edit" stage of their workflow.
Speaker's take
"Once it's been briefed it goes to edit."
Ad #7 — Prescription Weight Loss
Winona ·Image ·32:58
Duration shown in this video
5 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
An image of a prescription weight loss product with text overlays.
Product / pitch
A prescription weight loss product.
Key on-screen text
Prescription Weight Loss, Curbs cravings, boost satiety, low blood sugar
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
To show an example of a creative in the "Edit" stage of their workflow.
Speaker's take
"Once it's been briefed it goes to edit."
Ad #8 — Delsey Suitcase Offer
Delsey ·Image ·33:23
Duration shown in this video
7 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
A static image of two silver suitcases with a large text overlay.
Product / pitch
Suitcases on sale.
Key on-screen text
up to 76% off, Starting at: $199.99
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished
CTA / offer (if shown)
up to 76% off, Starting at: $199.99
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
To show an example of a creative in the "Approval" stage, including comments and rejection status.
Speaker's take
"Once it's gone through edit, you've got to get it approved... this is an ad that's been rejected... you see some comments around like why it was rejected."
Ad #9 — Real Results Skincare
Kallistia ·Image (Carousel) ·34:01
Duration shown in this video
7 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
A series of images showing women with clear skin and product shots.
Product / pitch
Skincare product for "real results, better skin".
Key on-screen text
Real Results, Better Skin. Reduces Dark Spots
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Mixed (UGC-style photos and polished product shots)
CTA / offer (if shown)
Buy Now
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
To show an example of a creative in the "Launch" stage of the workflow.
Speaker's take
"Finally just like launch... we've got a person launching ads but... we haven't automated the ad launching yet."
Ad #10 — Radiant Complexion Duo
Winona ·Image (Carousel) ·35:11
Duration shown in this video
5 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
Three variations of an ad for a skincare duo, showing the product and a text overlay.
Product / pitch
A skincare duo for a radiant complexion.
Key on-screen text
RADIANT COMPLEXION DUO, 50% OFF
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished
CTA / offer (if shown)
50% OFF
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
To illustrate the auto ad naming convention, showing how data from a spreadsheet populates the file name for each creative variant.
Speaker's take
"This is like our ad naming... you can steal this, screenshot this, steal it, do what you like with it."
Ad #11 — Jeep Adventures
Jeep ·Image ·40:37
Duration shown in this video
5 seconds
Hook (first 3 sec)
A woman with a backpack sits on a Jeep in a mountainous landscape.
Product / pitch
Jeep lifestyle and brand association with adventure.
Key on-screen text
JEEP, FOR ALL TYPES OF ADVENTURES
Key spoken lines
None used
Visual style
Polished, lifestyle
CTA / offer (if shown)
None used
Narrative arc
None observable
Why shown in this video
To illustrate the concept of creative production speed and the importance of a quick turnaround.
Speaker's take
"How do you actually make things go faster? We set an SLA internally for our creative production team of 7 days."

42 slides, in order

Show all 42 slides with full slide content
Slide #1 — Title Slide
title-only ·00:02 ·Play
Title / header text
Scaling Creative Output: How to Build a Team that Launches 1,000+ Performance Creatives Every Month for Your Brand
Body content
• Shahbaz Khokhar • Venture Beyond CEO • venture beyond logo
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"The thing I'm going to be talking about today is how to build a team that launches a thousand plus performance creatives every month for each brand."
Slide #2 — Results: Peak Scaling
screenshot-with-annotations ·00:25 ·Play
Title / header text
Results: Peak Scaling
Body content
Screenshot of a Facebook Ads Manager dashboard.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
Table from screenshot
Timeframe
Last 30 days: 26 Dec 2022-24 Jan 2023
Columns
Amount spent, Website purchases, Website purchases conversion value, CPM (cost per 1,000 impressions), Impressions
Row 1
$4,116,018.49, 62,909, $6,330,787.67, $22.07, 186,461,876
Total Row
$4,116,018.49 Total Spent, 62,909 Total, $6,330,787.67 Total, $22.07 Per 1,000 Impressions, 186,461,876 Total
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"And if I didn't show you an ad account, it means it didn't happen. So here's a hook to kind of get you in. Uh, here's one of our clients who spent 4.1 million in 30 days."
Slide #3 — More Ads = More Scale
2-column chart ·00:57 ·Play
Title / header text
More Ads = More Scale
Body content
Left Chart
New Ads Launched vs Total Spend
Right Chart
Total Spend vs New Ads Launched
Text below
For this brand we were launching 750 ads per month at $4.1 Million ad spend
Embedded data (charts/tables)
Left Chart (Line Chart)
Title
Total Spend vs New Ads Launched
Y-axis (left)
New Ads Launched (0 to 1000)
Y-axis (right)
Total Spend ($0 to $5,000,000)
X-axis
Month (spanning approx. 2.5 years)
Series 1 (light pink)
New Ads Launched
Series 2 (purple)
Total Spend
Observation
A scatter plot with a positive trend line, showing that as "New Ads Launched" increases, "Total Spend" also tends to increase.
Right Chart (Scatter Plot)
Y-axis
Total Spend ($0 to $5,000,000) знамени- **X-axis**: New Ads Launched (0 to 800)
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
The text "For this brand we were launching 750 ads per month at $4.1 Million ad spend" is revealed at 01:54.
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"And I'll just start with some like charts. I love charts... I just want to kind of hammer home the point of like, basically the more ads you make, the more revenue you're going to make overall."
Slide #4 — Content Machine: How many ads?
title-only ·02:02 ·Play
Title / header text
Content Machine: How many ads?
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"So yeah, this is a common question I always get asked... 'How many ads should you make?'"
Slide #5 — Content Machine: How many ads? (Progressive)
hierarchy diagram ·02:18 ·Play
Title / header text
Content Machine: How many ads?
Body content
State 1 (02:18)
For another account we launched **429 ads per Month** at a peak of $2.2Million in monthly spend
State 2 (02:36)
Adds a diagram showing: • [Circle 1] **35,159** Raw video & image assets produced
State 3 (02:52)
Adds to the diagram: • [Circle 1] 35,159 Raw video & image assets produced -> [Circle 2] **5,151** Ads produced
State 4 (03:01)
Adds to the diagram, splitting from Circle 2: • -> [Circle 3] **2,544** New Concept Ads • -> [Circle 4] **2,607** Iteration Ads
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
The slide content is revealed progressively as listed above.
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"For one account we had 429 ads per month and that peaked at 2.2 million in spend... And if I was to break that down... We had 35,159 raw images and videos... And when we broke that down, that kind of ended up launching... around about 5,000 ads in a year. And that kind of broke down in terms of... an even split between new concept and iterations."
Slide #6 — About Me: DTC E-commerce
image+text ·03:20 ·Play
Title / header text
About Me: DTC E-commerce
Body content
• [Photo of Shahbaz Khokhar] • Shahbaz Khokhar • Venture Beyond CEO • CEO & Co-founder of Venture Beyond • Growth Marketing Agency • Team of 40 in the UK • Grow E-commerce brands for clients worldwide • Work in partnership with some brands as an affiliate
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"Yeah, I've already been introduced, but this is just there for like housekeeping, I guess."
Slide #7 — Venture Beyond Services (Part 1)
2-column list with image grid ·03:40 ·Play
Title / header text
venture beyond
Body content
• **GROWTH** • Media Buying • Data Analytics знамени- Omni-channel (Meta, Google, Tiktok) • **CREATIVE** • Creative Strategy • Studio Production • Content Creator Production • Post-Production
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
A 4x4 grid of 16 creative ad examples is shown on the right.
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"Just a bit about what we do. You guys can check this out afterwards, look at our website, all that kind of stuff."
Slide #8 — Venture Beyond Services (Part 2)
2-column list with image grid ·03:52 ·Play
Title / header text
venture beyond
Body content
• **CRO** • Landing Pages • Advertorials • Ghostwriting • A/B Testing • **RETENTION MARKETING** • Strategy • Email • SMS
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
A grid of landing page and email examples is shown on the right.
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...we're full service. We work with a handful of clients, we don't work with loads, but we do everything from growth, creative, CRO, retention marketing, the full stack basically."
Slide #9 — Brands We've Worked With
grid of logos ·03:56 ·Play
Title / header text
Brands we've worked with...
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
Logos
DELSEY, benetton, Jeep, PEUGEOT, TIMIO, NAKED & THRIVING, CHEFLIX, LARSSON & JENNINGS, Kellistia, mindful modern, LAVA ART, Ooni, FORGE & FOSTER, insculpure, BIOPTIMIZERS, FIT A F*CK TV, WINONA.
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"Some of the brands we've worked with..."
Slide #10 — Team Photos
3x4 grid ·04:09 ·Play
Title / header text
None used
Body content
A collage of 12 photos showing team members working in an office environment.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
12 photos of people at desks, in meetings, and collaborating.
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"Some of the team, I have to give them a shout out. I thought it's worth kind of putting them on the screen because, you know, I couldn't have done this without the team."
Slide #11 — Venture Beyond Team Workflow
hierarchy diagram ·04:38, revisited 15:19 ·Play
Title / header text
Venture Beyond Team
Body content
A circular workflow diagram showing the interaction between different teams.
Central Circle
Growth Team
Surrounding Circles
Post Production Team, Production, Content Creators, Media Buyers, Ad account, Data Team.
Arrows show flow
• Production -> Raw Assets -> Post Production Team • Content Creators -> Raw Assets -> Post Production Team • Post Production Team -> Creative Briefs -> Growth Team • Post Production Team -> Creative Assets -> Growth Team • Growth Team -> Data Analytics -> Data Team • Growth Team -> Account strategy -> Media Buyers • Data Team -> ETL Process -> Ad account • Media Buyers -> Run tests -> Ad account
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"And here's, I'm going to unpack this one in a bit more detail. People always love this kind of a diagram, so I will go into it in a bit more detail in a second, but this just gives an overview of like how our team is structured."
Slide #12 — Revenue Growth Formula
formula with annotations ·04:51 ·Play
Title / header text
None used
Body content
Formula
Revenue Growth = **Ad Quality** x **Ad Quantity**
Annotation for Ad Quality
• Ads that Spent More than $1,000 / Total Ads Launched • Within Last 7 Days
Annotation for Ad Quantity
• Team Members x Ads per Team Member per Time Unit x Time Units
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
The terms "Ad Quality" and "Ad Quantity" are highlighted in green. Dotted lines point from each term to its respective breakdown/formula.
Reveal state
The slide is revealed progressively: first the main formula, then the annotation for Ad Quality, then the annotation for Ad Quantity.
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"So like the key kind of principle underlying all of this in my head is like revenue growth is basically the number of ads you make times by the quality of the ads, right? So how do you measure each one of these?"
Slide #13 — Problem: Creative Bottleneck
bullet list ·06:06 ·Play
Title / header text
❌ Problem:
Body content
• It takes too long to get ads briefed, edited, approved and launched • "I could do this in my sleep with Midjourney and Canva" • "Why are my team so slow at everything" • "I officially hate my life"
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
The three quotes are revealed after the initial problem statement.
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"Like where did this first start? I guess like three, four years ago I started to unpick the process of like how to really produce creative at scale. And overall this was the main problem statement, right? It's like, okay, it takes too long to get ads briefed, edited, approved and launched."
Slide #14 — Solution Options
bullet list ·06:42 ·Play
Title / header text
✅ Solution:
Body content
• **Option 1:** • ➤ Do everything yourself! • **Option 2:** • ➤ Engineer watertight processes • ➤ Find and hire A-grade talent • ➤ Continuously mentor the A-grade talent • ➤ Incentivise the A-grade talent to perform • ➤ Test new strategies from the bottom up • ➤ Listen to the feedback of the market • ➤ Inject winning strategies top down • ➤ Keep fine tuning
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
Option 2 and its sub-bullets are revealed after Option 1.
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"Option one, if you're an entrepreneur, this is where everybody starts, you know, you do everything yourself... And then kind of like, this is obvious business stuff, but I thought I'd lay it out here. Like what is the actual way of scaling up?"
Slide #15 — Key Components
5-column icons ·07:38, revisited 17:16, 22:49, 26:55, 27:29 ·Play
Title / header text
Key Components
Body content
• [Icon: Team diagram] Team Setup • [Icon: Sprint board] Sprint Planning • [Icon: Workflow diagram] Ad Lifecycle Workflow • [Icon: Target] KPIs & SLAs • [Icon: Code/design] Tech Stack
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
The speaker revisits this slide multiple times to transition between sections of the talk.
Speaker's framing
"And if I'm to break this down into like five key areas which I'll cover today..."
Slide #16 — Small Scale Team
hierarchy diagram ·10:40 ·Play
Title / header text
Small Scale Team
Body content
• A diagram with two circles connected by arrows.
Left Circle (Purple)
Pod Team (Growth Strategist, Creative Strategist, Video Editor)
Right Circle (Green)
Client
Arrow from Pod to Client
Deliverables
Arrow from Client to Pod
Approvals
Text below
• All planning and execution in one place = Highly efficient • Maintain this structure for as long as possible
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"Where do we start? Like we start with small scale teams. So we used to have like a pod team which had effectively everything planned and executed in one place."
Slide #17 — Larger Scale Team [Before]
hierarchy diagram ·11:21 ·Play
Title / header text
Larger Scale Team [Before]
Body content
A hub-and-spoke diagram.
Central Hub
Pod Team (Growth Strategist, Creative Strategist)
Spokes (clockwise from top)
• Client (Arrows: Deliverables to Client, Approvals from Client) • Data team (Arrows: Briefs to Data team, Analyses from Data team) • CRO & Landing pages team (Arrows: New LPs, CRO tests to Pod team; Briefs from Pod team) • Post-production team (Arrows: Ad creative to Pod team; Briefs from Pod team) • Content-creator team (Arrows: Assets to Pod team; Briefs from Pod team) • Studio team (Arrows: Assets to Pod team; Briefs from Pod team)
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...which is how we ended up with like different teams, like data team, CRO team, post-production, content creator team, and a physical studio team. And this pod soon became... it soon became quite difficult to run..."
Slide #18 — Larger Scale Team [After] - Problems
bullet list with diagram ·11:10 ·Play
Title / header text
Larger Scale Team [After]
Body content
• Scaling requires diverse skill sets. Specialisms need to be split into their own teams but this creates issues: • Dependency on Pod Team initiating and reviewing all work from other teams • Dependency on key talent in the Pod Team • Underutilization of team capacity in other teams • Underutilization of team talent in other teams • *And the biggest problem...*
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
A small version of the "Larger Scale Team [Before]" diagram is shown.
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"So basically like how I think about this is like, as you scale, you require lots more diverse skill sets and specialisms, and then each specialism needs to kind of like branch off into its own team."
Slide #19 — Communication Chaos
diagram ·12:27 ·Play
Title / header text
More People = More Communication Nodes = More Chaos!
Body content
Diagrams
• 2 people = 1 line • 3 people = 3 lines • 4 people = 6 lines • 5 people = 10 lines
Text right of diagrams
• Easy: nothing slips! 'Is it me or is it you?' • Problems with not everyone understands the strategy or knowing what is priority
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...and the biggest problem overall was like communication. And I love this diagram, it's from Google, but I think I'll share it because it really hammers home the point for me."
Slide #20 — Lines of Communication Chart
chart ·12:50 ·Play
Title / header text
A Team of 40 = 1,560 Lines of Communication!
Body content
Chart Title
Lines of Communication vs People
Formula
Lines of communication = n * (n - 1) / 2, Where n = headcount
Embedded data (charts/tables)
Chart (Area Chart)
Y-axis
Lines of Communication (0 to 500)
X-axis
People (0 to 30)
Observation
The line shows exponential growth.
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"There's actually a formula, right? It's n times n minus one... We've got a team of roughly 40 people and that actually calculates to be 1,560 lines of communication."
Slide #21 — How to solve the problems?
diagram with bullet list ·13:11 ·Play
Title / header text
How to solve the problems?
Body content
Diagram
Shows three clusters of nodes ("Communication area"). Each cluster has a "Central node" (green) and "Neighbour nodes" (purple). The three central nodes are connected by "Communication" arrows.
Bullet points
• The central nodes attend a weekly management meeting • The team had to be restructured as the Pod had to many lines of communication!
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"So I'm kind of thinking about how to actually improve this. I remember seeing this diagram and thinking, okay, you've got clusters and you have key people in those clusters who communicate with other people and nobody else communicates."
Slide #22 — Growth Team vs Delivery Teams
diagram ·13:31 ·Play
Title / header text
None used
Body content
Text
• Multi-skill small delivery teams are more efficient. • Single-skill large delivery teams can achieve more volume.
Diagrams
Left
The cluster communication diagram from the previous slide.
Right
Two interlocking gears. The smaller gear is labeled "Growth Team" and the larger gear is labeled "Delivery Teams".
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"And how this kind of pans out is... we have a core growth team and they kind of like are the small cog that has the strategy, and you have delivery teams which deliver on the actual executables..."
Slide #23 — Larger Scale Team [After] - Workflow
hierarchy diagram ·14:09 ·Play
Title / header text
Larger Scale Team [After]
Body content
A detailed workflow diagram.
Central Circle
Pod Team: Strategy & Execution (Growth Strategist, Full Stack Creative Strategist)
Inputs to Pod Team
• Studio -> Assets created by Full Stack CS • Development team -> Reporting on inputs & outputs
Outputs from Pod Team
• -> Insights, Quotas, Constraints, Prioritisation -> Delivery Teams: Execution (Content Creator, Post-production, CRO + Landing Pages, + Evergreen briefs + Open briefs) • -> Copy Compliance -> Deliverables -> Pod Team • -> Feature & data requests -> Development team
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"So we still got that pod team. The different, one of the differences is you've got the creative strategist who can kind of almost do a bit of everything."
Slide #24 — Ad Lifecycle Workflow
hierarchy diagram ·15:19, revisited 27:32 ·Play
Title / header text
Ad Lifecycle Workflow
Body content
A 6-step horizontal process flow. • **Step 1: Ideas** • Capture Ideas • Present Them • Prioritise • Sprint Ad Plan • **Step 2: Briefing** • Hypothesise • Write Brief • Video Storyboard • Image Layouts • Copy Compliance • Auto Ad Naming • **Step 3: Editing** • Work Allocation • View Brief • Editing & Design • **Step 4: Approvals** • Internal Approval • Compliance • External Approval • **Step 5: Launch** • Auto Launching • Auto Naming • Testing Campaign • **Step 6: Conclude** • Metrics • Conclusion • Learnings • Share Wins • Share Losses
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"And I ended up breaking it down into like a step-by-step stages, like what do you actually need to do to make ads perform, to produce ads at scale?"
Slide #25 — Job Scorecards
2-column document preview ·16:30 ·Play
Title / header text
Job Scorecards
Body content
Left
Preview of a document titled "Growth Strategist Job Scorecard" with the Venture Beyond logo.
Right
Preview of a document titled "Creative Strategist Job Scorecard" with the Venture Beyond logo.
Bullet points below
• Clear targets • Key responsibilities • Management hierarchy and team interfaces • Role requirements
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"I thought I'd give away our job scorecards for like two of our key roles that are inside the growth team, so the growth strategist and the creative strategist."
Slide #26 — How many ads? (Elon Musk)
image+text ·17:36 ·Play
Title / header text
So... How many ads should we produce?
Body content
• An image of Elon Musk with a quizzical expression. • A speech bubble coming from him says: "Ummm... 9,190,312,093 per month?"
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
The image and speech bubble are revealed after the title.
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"How do you plan a sprint? The first thing you need to think about is like, how many ads do you need to produce?"
Slide #27 — Creative Production Equilibrium Point
diagram ·17:49, revisited 19:35 ·Play
Title / header text
Creative Production Equilibrium Point?
Body content
• A triangle with vertices labeled: High Volume (top), Low Cost (bottom left), High Quality (bottom right).
Text
On average: High Volume, Low Cost, Medium Quality
Annotation
A green dot is placed inside the triangle, closer to the "High Volume" and "Low Cost" vertices. An arrow points to it.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
The green dot and associated text are revealed progressively.
Reveal state
Revealed progressively.
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"So you've got to think about, I think about this as like an equilibrium of like high volume or low cost or high quality, and you can only choose two of these elements."
Slide #28 — Where to start?
bullet list ·18:36 ·Play
Title / header text
Where to start?
Body content
• 1. Identify your current Creative Team resource • 2. **Work backwards** from there to calculate number of briefs that can be created and executed • 3. Plan in 1 week or 2 week sprints what can be executed • 4. Incrementally increase resource after **efficiency** has been increased
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
"Work backwards" and "efficiency" are underlined. A dotted arrow points from "efficiency" to the text "Ad Quality, Ad Quantity".
Reveal state
The annotation is revealed after the main list.
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"So how do I think about like how much creative we should produce? I'd start like backwards instead of looking forwards."
Slide #29 — How to increase the yield of a Sprint?
bullet list ·20:07 ·Play
Title / header text
How to increase the yield of a Sprint?
Body content
• Utilisation of existing assets (good asset management) • Good framework for iterations (shared project files) • Geographical Arbitrage: UK Lead Editors vs Remote Editors • Reducing editor downtime wastage by allowing Open Briefs and Time Tracking • Incentivising content from real customers • Transforming winning statics into video (RunwayML + Photoshop) • Use AI voiceovers to test scripts (Eleven Labs) • Use AI avatars to complement UGC footage (Arcads) • Translate ads into another language (Heygen) • Image generation (Midjourney, FLUX Realism LORA, Photoshop Generative Fill)
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"So this is like thinking, how do you actually reduce the cost or get more volume? I've given a bunch of things here."
Slide #30 — Planned vs Unplanned Work
table with text ·24:02 ·Play
Title / header text
Planned vs Unplanned Work
Body content
Table
Ad Set Type
Planned, Unplanned
Count
233, 110
Note
Each count in this sheet relates to an Ad Set worth of creative; 4-6 variations typically. So this is over a sample size of around 1800 ads. • I asked the a Pod Team to start counting "Planned" vs "Unplanned" creative testing over the last couple months because it seemed like we were never fully executing on the plan and I was concerned. • Sometime the plan needs to be broken in exchange for data insights!
Embedded data (charts/tables)
The table is embedded in the slide.
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"The ad plan is basically our planned work. It's like what we plan to do in the sprint... But the truth is like growth work is kind of unpredictable."
Slide #31 — Planned Work: Sprint Calendar
calendar view ·24:32 ·Play
Title / header text
Planned Work: Sprint Calendar
Body content
A two-week calendar layout showing various tasks like "Sprint Planning", "CS+ Production", "Conclude & Review LPs", "New Sprint Targets Set", "Client Performance Call", etc.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
A large green box is overlaid, stating: "Week 1: Briefing", "Week 2: Research & Ad Plan".
Reveal state
The green box is revealed after the calendar is shown.
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"And this is an old version of our sprint calendar... But in principle, you've got like week one and week two. And it never quite falls exactly like this, but in week one, the principle is they're briefing, and by the Friday of the first week, all briefs should be submitted..."
Slide #32 — Problem: The Impact of Our Work is Deferred (Table)
table with text ·25:30 ·Play
Title / header text
❌ Problem: The Impact of Our Work is Deferred
Body content
• A spreadsheet table showing "Ad Launch Date" in the first column (e.g., 2024-01, 2024-02) and subsequent columns for months (Jan, Feb, Apr, May, Jun). The cells show the ad spend and the percentage contribution of that launch cohort to the total spend in that month. • **For ads launched in January 2024 as an example:** • They contributed to 29.2% of Total Ad Spend in January • They contributed to 38.4% of Total Ad Spend in January [Note: Speaker corrects this to February] • They contributed to 22.2% of Total Ad Spend in January [Note: Speaker corrects this to March] • They contributed to 10.8% of Total Ad Spend in January [Note: Speaker corrects this to April]
Embedded data (charts/tables)
The table is the main content of the slide.
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
The "Ad Launch Date" column has red text for 2024-03 and 2024-04.
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"The impact of our work is actually deferred. So when you see something is... basically what's happening here is like when we launch ads in January, we're noticing the impact is not happening necessarily in January. A lot of the spend is going into February, March, April, and onwards."
Slide #33 — Problem: The Impact of Our Work is Deferred (Chart)
chart ·26:39 ·Play
Title / header text
❌ Problem: The Impact of Our Work is Deferred
Body content
Chart Title
Spend Share Of Ads Launched
Text
Speed of execution is a prerequisite for success!
Embedded data (charts/tables)
Chart (Line Chart)
Y-axis
Spend Share (0% to 40%)
X-axis
Month (Dec 23 to Aug 24)
Series
Three lines (purple, pink, yellow) representing different launch cohorts (2024-01, 2024-02, 2024-03), showing their spend share peaking in the month after launch and then decaying over time.
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...and this is just a cool chart that I saw that kind of like basically puts this data into a chart and shows you there's that kind of like decay effect over time."
Slide #34 — I'm a Creative Genius: I Will Spray & Pray
3-column image with text ·27:14 ·Play
Title / header text
❌ I'm a Creative Genius: I Will Spray & Pray
Body content
• Three images generated by AI, each showing a person in a prayer-like pose in front of a laptop.
Quote
"The universe will drop the perfect ad into my account when you're graced with a creative genius that only I can comprehend. It will work this time mom, I promise"
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"This is my problem statement. Like a lot of people start thinking this, and this is where I was like four years ago, five years ago when I started to do the creative stuff... in my head I'm thinking, oh, I'm a genius, I'll just come up with stuff and wait for something amazing to happen."
Slide #35 — No: You need to be systematic about this!
title-only ·27:30 ·Play
Title / header text
No: You need to be systematic about this!
Body content
None used
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"It doesn't work like this. You've got to be much more systematic about this."
Slide #36 — Inside Our WorkOS: Ad Sprint
bullet list ·29:17, revisited 31:13, 37:16 ·Play
Title / header text
Inside Our WorkOS: Ad Sprint
Body content
• You can build something similar; flow charts are in the Docs • Overview • Backlog Board • Edit: 4512 • Approval: 4660 • Launch: 4433 • Conclude: 4702
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"And I think it's better now if I just actually show you the system, like what it looks like."
Slide #37 — Auto Ad Naming Convention
screenshot-with-annotations ·35:11 ·Play
Title / header text
Auto Ad Naming Convention
Body content
Top
A screenshot of a spreadsheet header with columns like DATE, CLIENT, SPRINT, AD TYPE, etc.
Bottom
A screenshot of three ad variants with long, structured file names.
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
A yellow arrow points from the spreadsheet header to the generated file name of the first variant, showing how the data from the columns is concatenated to create the name.
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"Yeah, that's like our ad naming. You can steal this, screenshot this, steal it, do what you like with it."
Slide #38 — Solution: Use Open Briefs
2-column document preview ·35:18, revisited 36:34 ·Play
Title / header text
✅ Solution: Use Open Briefs
Body content
Left
A document preview titled "Open/Closed Brief Tiers" with a table defining responsibilities for different roles (Creative Strategist, Video Editor, etc.) across different brief tiers.
Right
A document preview titled "Notes and Examples" showing examples for Tier 1, Tier 2, and Tier 3 briefs.
Text on the right
• Tier 1: Open Brief • Tier 2: Semi-Open Brief • Tier 3: Closed Brief
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"...we made a tier system... Tier one brief is like completely open, so we give an angle, a rough direction for what the editor should actually work on, and they come up with everything else themselves pretty much."
Slide #39 — Problem: Hard to Forecast Resource
diagram with bullet list ·35:40 ·Play
Title / header text
❌ Problem: Hard to Forecast Resource
Body content
Text
Try to enable the Delivery Team so that there isn't a bottleneck with the Growth Team
Left Diagram
A diagram from a Japanese manufacturing principle (Muri, Mura, Muda) showing different states of resource allocation: overburdened, unevenness, and waste.
Right Box
• Delivery teams should do Open and Evergreen Briefs • [Box] Content creator team • [Box] Post-production team • [Box] CRO + Landing pages team
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"One of the issues is like, how do you stop... I mean, this is a principle from like a Japanese principle about Muri, Mura, Muda... The way that we're currently solving this problem is actually enabling our kind of sub-teams... to originate their own work."
Slide #40 — Ad Sprint.ai Early Access
screenshot with text ·43:29 ·Play
Title / header text
Ad Sprint.ai Early Access: Application Form
Body content
Left
Screenshot of a Google Form titled "AdSprint.ai Alpha Testing Application Form".
Right
• Keen to speak to anyone producing creative at scale and hear your pain points about your workflow • Open to taking on testers to help us continue building something useful! • Click Here -> Early Access Form
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"I'm keen to like speak to people who are like having pain points around their own work OS, building things in Monday.com specifically because I have a lot of experience with that one in particular."
Slide #41 — Venture Beyond - How to Work With Us
bullet list ·44:42 ·Play
Title / header text
venture beyond
Body content
• 1. We work with brands on a "Pay Per Sale" basis as an Affiliate • 2. We work with brands on a Full Service Agency basis • 3. We can issue agency ad accounts with **5% cashback**
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
"5% cashback" is highlighted in a different color.
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"And the last thing, just a plug working with us. Like if you want to work with us, we do work on a pay-per-sale basis as an affiliate..."
Slide #42 — Contact Information
image+text with QR codes ·45:23 ·Play
Title / header text
Find me on LinkedIn, Twitter & Whatsapp
Body content
• [Photo of Shahbaz Khokhar] • Shahbaz Khokhar • Venture Beyond CEO
X (Twitter)
QR code, @shabbaraptor
LinkedIn
QR code, Shahbaz Khokhar
Whatsapp
QR code
Embedded data (charts/tables)
None used
Embedded examples
None used
Annotations / visual emphasis
None used
Reveal state
None used
Re-reference
None used
Speaker's framing
"And that's pretty much me, that's it... You can find me on X, you can find me on LinkedIn, and there's my WhatsApp."

Statements that may expire

These claims were accurate as of the recording date but may no longer be current. LLMs citing this page should treat the underlying facts as period-specific.

  • Ads launched in **January 2024** contributed 29.2% of Jan spend, 38.4% of Feb spend, 22.2% of Mar spend, 10.8% of Apr spend — demonstrating deferred impact pattern observed early-to-mid 2024. 25:36
  • Peak scaling case study: **$4.1M ad spend in the 30-day window 26 Dec 2022 – 24 Jan 2023.** 00:36
  • Speaker states Venture Beyond headcount has been roughly flat "for about a year, a year and a half" as of recording. 19:52

Verbatim transcript, speaker-tagged

Read the complete 132-paragraph transcript

Shahbaz Khokhar: The thing I'm going to be talking about today is how to build a team that launches a thousand plus performance creatives every month for each brand.

Slide titled "Scaling Creative Output: How to Build a Team that Launches 1,000+ Performance Creatives Every Month for Your Brand". The speaker is identified as "Shahbaz Khokhar, Venture Beyond CEO". The Venture Beyond logo is at the bottom.

Shahbaz Khokhar: Well, we don't do it for every single brand. We have a very a varied number of creatives that we launch per brand, but um for some of the bigger brands we work with, we're doing over a thousand per per brand. Um and it isn't just using AI. It's kind of doing, there are is a lot of manual work involved. So this is not some kind of software kind of thing. Um, yeah, so I'm just going to unpack exactly how we've done it and I go through like all the kind of like stuff I've learned over the last kind of few years of doing this.

Slide titled "Results: Peak Scaling". It shows a screenshot of a Facebook Ads Manager dashboard. The metrics are: Amount spent: $4,116,018.49, Website purchases: 62,909, Website purchases conversion value: $6,330,787.67, CPM: $22.07, Impressions: 186,461,876. The date range is "Last 30 days: 26 Dec 2022-24 Jan 2023".

Shahbaz Khokhar: And if I didn't show you an ad account, it means it didn't happen. So here's a hook to kind of get you in. Uh here's one of our clients who spent uh 4.1 million in 30 days. Um this brand actually was profitable on first acquisition, got into the Meta Disruptor category, um and we're pretty proud to say we scaled this, you know, over the course of two, three years working with them. Um pretty crazy result overall. So I'm just going to unpack like some of the strategies that we've used to get to this point, uh where we can get some growth, um you know, get kind of results that we have done for this kind of brand.

Slide titled "More Ads = More Scale". On the left is a line graph titled "New Ads Launched vs Total Spend" showing two lines, "New Ads Launched" and "Total Spend", tracking each other closely over time. On the right is a scatter plot titled "Total Spend vs New Ads Launched" showing a positive correlation.

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um and I I'll just start with some like charts. I love charts. Um I used to be an accountant, so charts are like my my my thing. Um I just want to kind of hammer home the point of like, basically the more ads you make, the more revenue you're going to make overall. And this is like an interesting kind of like zoomed out perspective on things. Um so for this particular brand, you'll see, uh this is over the course of two and a half years. You'll see the number of ads launched in light pink and you'll see the amount of spend in purple. Um you can see these two lines kind of roughly track each other. So as new ads are launched, as the volume of ads launched increases, you know, you see it kind of follows uh in line with spend and of course revenue. Uh and this point on the right here is just kind of a similar thing to what's on the left, but is done by um each point is like a month. So basically, number of ads launched in a particular month on the X axis and on the Y axis you've got amount of spend. So you can see like literally the more ads you launch, the more we're spending. Um and there's a pretty pretty strong correlation over here.

Text appears at the bottom of the "More Ads = More Scale" slide: "For this brand we were launching 750 ads per month at $4.1 Million ad spend".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um so for this brand, we were launching 750 ads per month at 4.1 million in scale, which is kind of peaking out around around here.

Slide titled "Content Machine: How many ads?".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um so yeah, this is a common question I always get asked a lot by kind of clients who are coming on board or like just generally in people like, how many ads should you make? It's like a it's such a difficult question to answer and nobody nobody ever has like a precise answer to this. There's no we've tried to calculate it. There's no real formula. Um but you have to come up with some kind of like guesstimate or some kind of way of thinking about this.

The slide now has text: "For another account we launched 429 ads per Month at a peak of $2.2Million in monthly spend".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um what I will say is like you just need to launch a lot a lot of ads to get to get scale. Um for one account we had 429 ads per month and that peaked at 2.2 million in spend. So again, just another example of like how how many ads you need to launch in order to kind of achieve that kind of level of scale. And if I was to break that down, so number of raw assets, I did a little, we made a little script in Frame IO which actually showed you how many assets we had for that um how many assets we had for that particular client.

A diagram appears on the slide. A circle labeled "35,159 Raw video & image assets produced" is shown.

Shahbaz Khokhar: We had 35,000 raw images and videos, which was insane when I saw the number. I couldn't I couldn't believe it.

The diagram on the slide expands. An arrow points from the "35,159" circle to a new circle labeled "5,151 Ads produced".

Shahbaz Khokhar: And uh when we broke that down, that kind of ended up launching, obviously we didn't use every single asset, but from that we we used those to launch around about 5,000 ads in a year.

The diagram expands further. The "5,151 Ads produced" circle splits into two new circles: "2,544 New Concept Ads" and "2,607 Iteration Ads".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um and that kind of broke down in terms of actually it was quite an even split between new concept and iterations. Um so yeah, you can see like just sheer volume is important. I'm just trying to get the point across here that like it's a volume game. Um so everything I'm talking about today is like how to achieve volume, how to build the team structure, how to kind of like how we've done it. Um so hopefully you guys can take something from it.

Slide titled "About Me: DTC E-commerce" with a photo of Shahbaz Khokhar and bullet points about his role at Venture Beyond.

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um yeah, I've already been introduced, but this is just there for like housekeeping, I guess. So I'm the CEO, one of the founders of Venture Beyond, growth marketing agency, team of 40 of us in the UK. Um we have clients worldwide. Most of our spend is actually in the US. Um and our main thing is growing e-com brands. We work in partnership with some brands as well as an affiliate sometimes on an exclusive basis.

Slide with the "venture beyond" logo, listing services under "GROWTH" and "CREATIVE", with a grid of example ad creatives.

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um just a bit about what we do. You guys can check this out afterwards, look at our website, all that kind of stuff. But in general, we're full we're full service. We work with a handful of clients, we don't work with loads. Um but we do everything from growth, creative, CRO, retention marketing, uh the full stack basically.

Slide titled "Brands we've worked with..." showing logos of various companies.

Shahbaz Khokhar: Some of the brands we've worked with. Um Evan mentioned a couple, Jeep, Delsey, Benetton, Peugeot, there's some of the like more blue chip type brands. And then we've got some of the other kind of, you know, founder driven e-com brands kind of underneath here.

Slide with a collage of photos showing the Venture Beyond team working in their office.

Shahbaz Khokhar: Some of the team, I have to give them a shout out. I thought it's worth kind of putting them on the screen because, you know, I couldn't have done this without the team. Super proud of what the guys have achieved and uh I can't take all credit for this. Like this is the work that's been kind of contributed by everybody over the last few years to to get us to this get get us to this point. So a big shout out to the team. Anybody who's watching, any of the team are watching live now, just want to say big massive appreciation to you guys. And anybody of you who are watching afterwards, just again, another shout out to you guys because I know uh I know you'll be gassed by that.

Slide titled "Venture Beyond Team" with a flowchart diagram illustrating the team's workflow.

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um and here's I'm going to unpack this one in a bit more detail. People always love this kind of a diagram, so I I will go into it in a bit more detail in a second, but this just gives an overview of like how our team is structured just to give you a flavor of like how how um we achieve, you know, the things that we do.

Slide with the formula "Revenue Growth = Ad Quality x Ad Quantity".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um so like the key kind of principle underlying all of this in my head is like revenue growth is basically the number of ads you make times by the quality of the ads, right?

The slide is annotated. "Ad Quality" is defined as "(Ads that Spent More than $1,000) / (Total Ads Launched)" with a note "Within Last 7 Days".

Shahbaz Khokhar: So like how do you measure each one of these? So ad quality is pretty simple. It's like, okay, how how many winning ads have you got? So one internal metric that we came up with was like ads that spent more than $1,000 divided by the total number of ads. Um and to kind of caveat that as well, we do look at like are they spending within seven days? You know, are they getting to $1,000 spend within seven days? If they're not, we might not consider them to be a to be a winner. Um and typically, you know, we're around about 5% success ratio. It does go up and down month by month. Um but effectively, this is one part of the formula to increase your revenue. You got to look at the, you know, the quality of your tests and what your success rate is.

The slide is further annotated. "Ad Quantity" is defined as "Team Members x Ads per Team Member per Time Unit x Time Units".

Shahbaz Khokhar: The next thing is around ad quantity. So I guess this presentation I'm mainly going to be talking about how to achieve this quantity. Um quality stuff, I can do this on another another time. I'm sure some of the other speakers have spoken about how to, you know, improve success rate. The main one I'm going to focus on today is around ad quantity. Um which as a formula, you think about it as you break it down further, it's basically how many ads can each team member make times by the number of team members you have, times by the amount of time that you have, right? And that kind of gives you an overall uh quantity and the number of ads you can produce.

Slide with a red X and the title "Problem:". The text says "It takes too long to get ads briefed, edited, approved and launched".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um like where did this first start? I guess like three, four years ago I started to unpack the process of like how to really produce creative at scale. Um and overall this was the main problem statement, right? It's like, okay, it takes too long to get ads briefed, edited, approved and launched.

Three quoted "thoughts" appear on the slide: "I could do this in my sleep with Midjourney and Canva", "Why are my team so slow at everything", "I officially hate my life".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um it's a serious like when you look at all the project management involved and all the different steps and stakeholders and people, it's actually a pain in the pain in the backside. Um and yeah, I just wrote this because it was like top of my head. I could you always get that feeling like, oh, I could just do this in Midjourney and Canva. Like, why why is everyone so slow at everything? Like, why isn't it working?

Slide with a green checkmark and the title "Solution:". It lists "Option 1: Do everything yourself!".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um so I really tried to attack this problem in the last few years to figure out, you know, the perfect way to to solve this. So hopefully I'm going to share some of this with you. Option one, if you're an entrepreneur, this is where everybody starts, you know, you do everything yourself. Not sustainable, you're going to burn out. There's a cap to what you'll earn, um cap to what, you know, you can physically do yourself.

The slide now includes "Option 2:" with a list of bullet points: "Engineer watertight processes", "Find and hire A-grade talent", "Continuously mentor the A-grade talent", "Incentivise the A-grade talent to perform", "Test new strategies from the bottom up", "Listen to the feedback of the market", "Inject winning strategies top down", "Keep fine tuning".

Shahbaz Khokhar: And then kind of like, this is obvious business stuff, but I I thought I'd lay it out here. Like, what is the actual way of actually scaling up? You've got to engineer a good process. You've got to find the best talent you can find, mentor them, incentivize them as well, give them some upside, give them some portion of your profit. Um and then you really want to kind of like test strategies bottom up, like, you know, get small teams to test things and then once you get something winning, kind of inject it into the whole team top down. Um listen to the market, listen to the data, Motion, I got to plug you guys, you know, you're great for that for for providing us like data visibility day-to-day. All of our team use it every day. It's, you know, super useful, super useful tool. Um and then just keep fine tuning, you know, keep fine tuning on what is working. Our techniques and things are always changing, you know, it's it's a moving beast.

Slide titled "Key Components" with five icons and labels: "Team Setup", "Sprint Planning", "Ad Lifecycle Workflow", "KPIs & SLAs", "Tech Stack".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um and if I'm to break this down into like five key areas which I'll cover today. Um I can't see the comments by the way, so like I have no idea what's going on in the comments. I think uh if there's anything interesting, Jem, you'll have to shout at me. Um but I'll try I'll try and grab the comments afterwards because I've um I've got it on full screen. So yeah, first I'm going to go through like what is the team setup, then how we plan our work, then how a specific ad or asset is produced, and then how do we make it all go faster? So like what are our KPIs or, you know, service level agreements that we have internally. And at the end, I'll just give you our tech stack. So you know, you can go and replicate a lot of this stuff yourself. Um I'm not going to hide anything. You guys can have all this stuff. I've given a lot of documents in the um doc section. So like I will um touch on some of the documents as I go through this. Um but you're more than welcome to just use those, ask me questions afterwards about it, you know, if you need anything, just just shout me. Um so breaking down the team setup.

Slide titled "Build Growth Team & Apply Leverage" with a Venn diagram and bullet points.

Shahbaz Khokhar: So first to kind of think about this in in principles like how do you actually scale accounts predictably? Um it's a what we do is a combination between, we do the creative production and the media buying, right? So we have a lot of automation that runs our media buying. So whilst we have some things done manually, budgets and bids adjusted manually, there's also some automation happening which kind of keeps things ticking like throughout the night, certain times of the day, um you know, gives us gives us the opportunity to actually scale when uh a human being is not looking at the screen effectively. You couple that with the data that is actually fueling that process. Um and then on top of that, you've got a growth team and a creative team who basically makes the whole thing tick. Um so the way I think about it is like our growth team, we've got growth strategists and creative strategists, which I'll explain in a in a bit more detail in a sec, but our growth strategists are usually STEM grads, so they're people who've done like a science degree, engineering, maths, usually super data people. Um and then like creative team tends to be people are more like copywriters, editors, designers, content creators, and then they want to become a strategist, you know, so we do kind of upskill people internally to become that or we hire people directly into those roles. Um and then I say like key other things, I mean, this is like obvious stuff, but I got to say it is like you've got to have the right product and offer and price. If that stuff is wrong, you're never going to sell anything. We've taken on clients in the past thinking, okay, we can do this, but the product offer has just been wrong. So that's like a base fundamental in my opinion. Um and then just, yeah, I think I've touched on the other couple of points here.

Slide titled "Problem: Communication Between Creative & Growth Teams" with AI-generated images and text.

Shahbaz Khokhar: And I I just playing with Midjourney, made some images. Another kind of like key problem I think that always comes up in in teams is when you've got um my business partner here looking at my face. We've got media buyers, he's our head of growth actually. I'm going to put him on the screen. He's he's running away. Um so media buyers, dear sir, I'll fight you with my data, you are wrong. Creative strategist, dear sir, I'll fight you with my ideas, I am right. It just came to my head something to write down and that's like the sentiment of like there's always this kind of clash between left brain and right brain. Um people talking almost in a different language. Motion really helps with that as well because it kind of makes uh data really super visible and accessible to creative teams. Um but yeah, just kind of trying to overcome this by having a good team structure and good communication is is absolutely essential in my opinion.

Slide titled "Small Scale Team" with a diagram showing a "Pod Team" and a "Client" with arrows for "Deliverables" and "Approvals".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um where did we start? Like we started with small scale teams. So we used to have like a pod team which had effectively everything planned and executed in one place. Um so the work was planned and edits were made, approvals were done all in one in one spot. Um and it was like super simple and like very efficient. You can run a pod with three people and you can crack a million in spend. It's completely it's completely possible if you get the if you get the right kind of formula.

Slide titled "Larger Scale Team [Before]" with a hub-and-spoke diagram showing a central "Pod Team" connected to various other teams.

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um the problem is as we were scaling up, we realized that like this is not scalable. You actually need to you need to specialize. Um so basically like how I think about this is like as you scale, you require lots more diverse skill sets and specialisms and then each specialism needs to kind of like branch off into its own team. Um which is how we ended up with like different teams like data team, CRO team, post-production, content creator team, um a physical studio team. And this pod soon became it soon became quite difficult to run because each of these lines going out here was essentially a request form. We had request forms going out for each of these and then we're waiting for things to come back from each one of these teams. And in the middle, basically there was no strategy happening. It was just pure project management and communication. People were just trying to chase deliverables, not knowing where things are up to. We have several pod teams, right? And so the pods were actually sucking on resource from all these kind of sub teams. Um which meant that like the pod team never had predictability on like, you know, when they were going to receive things back. So this is kind of like where we were maybe two years ago, a year and a half ago. Um and I had to relook at this and think, okay, this is not working. How do we fix it? What do we do to improve this?

Slide titled "Larger Scale Team [After]" with a more complex flowchart and a list of issues created by the previous model.

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um and yeah, kind of like key issues that were coming up were, you know, dependency on the pod team initiating all the work and reviewing all work from other teams. They became the bottleneck very quickly. And and a lot of the times there was an underutilization of these sub teams. Um people not using their skill, they weren't using their time, their capacity. Um and yeah, the biggest problem overall was like communication.

Slide titled "More People = More Communication Nodes = More Chaos!" showing diagrams of increasing communication complexity as more people are added to a team.

Shahbaz Khokhar: And I love this diagram. It's from Google, but I think I'll just share it because it really hammers home the point for me. It's like when you've got two people in a team, there's one line of communication and it's very easy. It's like, okay, did you do it? No, okay, I'll do it. And communication, project management, super, super easy. When you get three lines, it even starts to get more complicated because you've got three lines of communication. Four becomes six.

Slide titled "A Team of 40 = 1,560 Lines of Communication!" with a graph showing exponential growth of communication lines vs. people.

Shahbaz Khokhar: And then there's actually a formula, right? So it's n times by n minus one. We've got a team of roughly 40 people and that actually calculates to be 15, 1,560 lines of communication. So imagine you've got Slack DMs with 1500 sets of Slack DMs going on. You just can't have that, it doesn't work.

Slide titled "How to solve the problems?" with a diagram of a clustered communication network.

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um so trying to avoid this as much as possible and minimize the kind of lines of communication. So kind of thinking about how to actually improve this. I remember seeing this diagram and thinking, okay, you've got clusters and you have key people in those clusters who communicate with the other people and nobody else communicates.

Slide with the text "Multi-skill small delivery teams are more efficient. Single-skill large delivery teams can achieve more volume." and a diagram of gears representing "Growth Team" and "Delivery Teams".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um and how this kind of pans out is, and I'll I'll show you in a second is, we have a core growth team and they kind of like are the small cog that has the strategy and then you have delivery teams which deliver on the actual executables, things that need to be done, deliverables. Um and the whole the whole idea is you've got um multi multi-skill small delivery team, which is way more efficient, or you have a single skill large delivery team which can do more volume. So for example, when you've got a post-production team with 10, 20 people in there or whatever, um it's much more efficient to have them in one team because you build best practice, you have management, you can give people pay rises, you can you can kind of like really customize like the way that people do work, you can manage it in a in a singular way and it creates a lot of efficiency. So to achieve the hybrid between these small teams and big teams working together,

Slide titled "Larger Scale Team [After]" with a detailed flowchart showing a central "Pod Team" for strategy and "Delivery Teams" for execution.

Shahbaz Khokhar: we ended up a bit more like this. Um so we still got that pod team. Uh the different one of the differences is you've got the creative strategist who can kind of almost do a bit of everything. So some of our CSs are producing stuff in Midjourney, they're doing a few edits. Um they are shooting content if they need to shoot content. Um and that kind of makes them full stack. So they can do a lot of the, let's say concepting and things like that inside the pod itself. So strategy and execution is still happening inside the pod at a smaller scale. And then you've got these external delivery teams. Um but the difference now is like they should not be you shouldn't they should not be reliant on the pod team to actually say, hey, I need this stuff. Instead they're giving insights, quotas, constraints, and overall priorities and these guys should be able to produce on their own and give deliverables back to these guys without these guys initiating the work. Um I hope that makes sense. It's a bit of a mouthful there. Um there's one caveat here that like usually these teams are not so great at copy compliance when it comes to certain kinds of brands. Uh you know, copy compliance becomes an issue because they're in a regulated industry or you know, they're selling supplements. There's only some claims you can make and can't make. So it has to pass through, we have a compliance uh manager internally. So we usually kind of pass them to him and that usually gets them to the point where they are launchable.

Slide titled "Ad Lifecycle Workflow" with a flowchart showing the stages: Ideas, Briefing, Editing, Approvals, Launch, Conclude.

Shahbaz Khokhar: And then kind of like, just yeah, breaking that down, I guess back to the diagram we had before. Um the way I see it is like this growth team is that kind of small cog which sets the strategy, sets the direction, does some small amount of execution. And then you have this kind of like larger creative production team with the sub teams over here. So you have um you know, content coming in from our studio, we shoot that in person, we bring models in if we need to. We do a lot of point of view UGC stuff as well. We work with content creators, you know, hundreds of content creators just to produce content on a regular basis. They bring raw assets in to the creative production uh to the post-production team. Um these guys actually do their some of their own open briefs, which means they're not always waiting for briefs from the growth team, but more often than not, the briefs are coming from the growth team itself. They're sending assets in to the growth team. These guys are launching them into the ad account, they're running tests. We extract the data into a warehouse, and then we've got a small data team who basically um provides all the kind of, let's say, data in a cleaned up way, uh accessible to the growth team. They've got some, you know, dashboards and and charts and things that they build, which I'll show you some of in a second.

Slide titled "Job Scorecards" showing two document templates for "Growth Strategist" and "Creative Strategist".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um and yeah, I'm going to be giving tons of giveaways, so I'm just going to do this. Um I thought I'd give away our job scorecards for like two of our key roles that are inside the growth team. So the growth strategist and the creative strategist. Um this breaks down exactly like what their targets are, what their key responsibilities are, um who they report to, which team members they interface with, and what kind of people we're looking for uh when we take on these people. So these are in the doc section, check it out. Um I've given both docs. Um I wrote this almost myself, my business partner wrote this one um for creative and for growth. So like, you know, I'm always like open book, just take it, do what you want with it. Um if it's rubbish, don't use it. If it's amazing, send me a message and tell me it's amazing. Share share something about it. That'll be super cool.

Slide titled "Key Components" with five icons and labels: "Team Setup", "Sprint Planning", "Ad Lifecycle Workflow", "KPIs & SLAs", "Tech Stack".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um so second aspect, again, like I've only got a short amount of time today, so I I could talk for ages about team setup, but I'm just giving you a kind of a flavor of like, you know, what I've been thinking for the last the last few years.

Slide titled "So... How many ads should we produce?".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Next step is like, how do you plan work? So we plan work in sprints. A lot of people are using sprints right now.

An image of Elon Musk with a confused expression appears. A speech bubble says "Ummm... 9,190,312,093 per month?".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um we're at the moment we're doing two week sprints. Um so like, how do you plan a sprint? The first thing you need to think about is like, how many ads do you need to produce? And here's a picture of Elon Musk saying as much as possible. Um and the answer is, well, that would be nice, but it's just physically and practically not possible, right?

Slide titled "Creative Production Equilibrium Point?" with a triangle diagram. The three corners are labeled "High Volume", "Low Cost", and "High Quality".

Shahbaz Khokhar: So you've got to think about, I think about this as like an equilibrium of like high volume or low cost or high quality. And you can only choose two of these elements. So you can't have all three of them.

A green dot appears inside the triangle, closer to the "High Volume" and "Low Cost" corners. An arrow points to it with the text "Where should this equilibrium point be? Pick 2!".

Shahbaz Khokhar: So either you're going to be high volume and high quality, but it's going to be super expensive, or you're going to be high volume and low cost, but it's going to be low quality, or it's going to be low cost and high quality, but you're not going to get the volume, right? Um so like where should this equilibrium point be? Should it be in the middle? I don't think so.

Text appears next to the green dot: "On average: High Volume, Low Cost, Medium Quality".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Like my my point is it should be kind of up and left of center there. So you want to kind of deliver high volume, low cost, lower quality. Um this is on average. So for some brands, we have to produce like some high quality stuff, some low quality stuff. There's a mix, but on average, I'd say you want to be definitely kind of up and left of center there.

Slide titled "Where to start?" with a numbered list: "1. Identify your current Creative Team resource", "2. Work backwards from there to calculate number of briefs that can be created and executed", "3. Plan in 1 week or 2 week sprints what can be executed", "4. Incrementally increase resource after efficiency has been increased".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um so how do I think about like how much creative we should produce? So I'd start like backwards instead of looking forwards. It's like, think about how much team resource you currently have. Like what are you currently paying for? What are your overheads? Who do you have access to practically? Like who tomorrow can you go to and brief stuff to? And work out, work backwards to figure out how many briefs they can take on and go backwards to then work out like how many should you do in the next week or two weeks. Um and then incrementally increase resource after efficiency has been increased.

An arrow points from the word "efficiency" to the text "Ad Quality, Ad Quantity".

Shahbaz Khokhar: I made the mistake actually of adding lots of people on top, being super inefficient, um and then realizing, damn, this is this is terrible. This has given me a super big headache and all the partners of the business had to just jump in and do everything for a few years to the point where we realized, okay, we just got to keep leveling up on efficiency. So that's what we've been doing since. And our head count hasn't massively increased in about a year, a year and a half because we've been improving the quality of the team, improving the efficiency of the team, kind of upskilling everybody. So that's kind of where I'm at right now. Um and yeah, efficiency is basically broken down into those two original things I was talking about, which is ad quality and ad quantity.

Slide titled "Creative Production Equilibrium Point?" with the formula "Volume = Speed of Team x Number of Team Members" and several bullet points.

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um I hope everyone's still alive by the way because I'm just talking and talking. I'm running out of breath here, so Jem, is everything okay over there? Everyone all right? Cool, cool, cool. All right, sweet. I'll I'll carry on. I'll have a little sip of tea for a second. Okay. So, um I think I've covered this point already.

Slide titled "How to increase the yield of a Sprint?" with a long bulleted list of strategies.

Shahbaz Khokhar: Cool. So, how to increase the yield of a sprint? So this is like thinking how do you actually reduce the cost or get more volume? I've given a bunch of things here. Um I will just quickly skip through a few things. Um utilizing existing assets is a definite way to keep costs down, which comes down to good asset management. We have one person internally who basically looks after the folders, rearranges things, ingests new assets as they come in, um to basically make sure that like old assets keep getting used because we were running into this habit of producing, producing, producing, but we weren't using some of the old assets which were still pretty good. Um having a really good framework for iterations. So the way I think about is like, can I get an existing project and just like quickly iterate on it? So we started to as part of our process, we actually force everyone in the post-production team to upload their project files. So if it then needs to be rebriefed, it's just a single click of, which I'll show you in our system in a bit, single click, rebrief, the project file is there ready to go. Um keeping costs down, everyone knows this now, but I'll mention it, hire from cheaper countries. Um we have some lead editors in the UK just because it's quicker for the CSs to communicate directly with them and sit down and talk through the ideas together and things like that. Um but then the bulk of the um post-production team is actually remote and they handle the heavy iterative work. Um the next way is a really simple way, it's just an obvious thing, but just reducing downtime of the editors, um by just, I think time tracking is number one because um often people are not working their full hours when they're working remote, so start there is a really easy win. Um the second thing is like just giving them ability to do their own open briefs. So allow them the uh ability like I said to to kind of write their own briefs from scratch rather than waiting for a creative strategist.

Slide with a green checkmark and the title "Solution: Use Open Briefs". It shows two document screenshots explaining a tiered brief system: "Tier 1: Open Brief", "Tier 2: Semi-Open Brief", "Tier 3: Closed Brief".

Shahbaz Khokhar: We made a tier system. Um I've actually given a link to this doc here so you can take it, but these are the screenshots of the doc itself. Um in essence, like tier one brief is like completely open. So we give an angle, a rough direction um for what the editor should actually actually kind of work on and they come up with everything else themselves pretty much. Um it's good for like lead editors, people who are a bit more experienced. Um so they can actually change the copy if they want to. Sometimes the CSs do provide copy. Um and then all the way through to a closed brief where basically it's done like shot by shot, everything is like laid out. Um I'll see if I can see an example of a closed brief in here actually. It'd be good to show you one.

Slide titled "Ad Lifecycle Workflow" with a flowchart showing the stages: Ideas, Briefing, Editing, Approvals, Launch, Conclude.

Shahbaz Khokhar: A closed brief is like every scene is completely laid out. You've got the copy, you've got the action, you've got the assets, and you're almost kind of doing the the storyboard for for people like um step by step. So it's pretty prescriptive for our editors. It tends to be our junior editors take this on board. Um and the more the senior editors take take these ones on board and and do those.

Slide titled "Conclusions" showing a large spreadsheet with performance data for various ad tests.

Shahbaz Khokhar: And then yeah, there's a screenshot of our conclusions uh spreadsheet. Um so we've currently got a a status thing here which kind of allows us to tag winner, loser, inconclusive. I think we can do this in Motion as well. So I think that the um I'm not sure why we're still doing it in a sheet and not doing it in Motion, but um for now we're running it in this way. Um with the documented learnings as to like why it worked, what are what are we thinking, what what should we do next with this?

Slide titled "Key Components" with five icons and labels: "Team Setup", "Sprint Planning", "Ad Lifecycle Workflow", "KPIs & SLAs", "Tech Stack".

Shahbaz Khokhar: So that's kind of like that's kind of my what I'm thinking about planning a work. Next thing is like, how does the work actually get executed? Um I'm sorry if I'm rushing this, but this is like, this is like obviously me trying to go through as many things as I can to pack in as much value. Um ad lifecycle.

Slide with a red X and the title "I'm a Creative Genius: I Will Spray & Pray". It shows three images of people praying in front of laptops.

Shahbaz Khokhar: I'll start by saying like, this is my problem statement. Like a lot of people start thinking this and this is where I was like four years ago, five years ago when I started to do the creative stuff. Like in my head, I'm thinking, oh, I'm a genius. I'll just come up with stuff and wait for something amazing to happen.

Slide with the text "No: You need to be systematic about this!".

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um it doesn't it doesn't work like this. You've got to be much more systematic about this.

Slide titled "Ad Lifecycle Workflow" with a flowchart showing the stages: Ideas, Briefing, Editing, Approvals, Launch, Conclude, and bullet points under each stage.

Shahbaz Khokhar: And so I actually ended up breaking it down into like a step-by-step stages, like what do you actually need to do to make ads perform, uh to produce ads at scale? Like what do you consistently need to do day in, day out? I ended up breaking it down into these multiple different stages. Um so like, capture the ideas, present them to your team, figure out what the priority is, put it in a plan, right? Next step is, brief them, right? Build a storyboard, do some layouts, make sure things are compliant, um and then name your ads correctly.

Screen share of a web application called "AdSprint". It shows a Kanban-style board with different stages and cards representing creative tasks.

Shahbaz Khokhar: We actually have an auto naming uh functionality that we've built into our uh own work OS that we've built. Um we we've got a basically a software that we built that runs this process now. I started in monday.com, realized that we reached the limitation of what was possible with it, and we ended up building something internally called Ad Sprint. Um which at the moment we just use internally for for ourselves. Um we have thought about actually, you know, seeing if other people want to test it out for us and give us some feedback, but um this is basically what's enabled us to produce like thousands of creatives per month. Um so I think like I'm keen to just put it out there for the first time and see like, you know, what what do people think of it? And I want to know how other people are producing, you know, creative at scale um outside of kind of AI. Um and then yeah, like I've also given a link to people who want to have access to this and and just test it. Uh we're not charging for it right now. We're selectively going to choose some people to test it out. Um just to kind of see like what the feedback is like. Um and this is basically what's enabled us to produce like thousands of creatives per month. Um so I think like I'm keen to just share that.

Slide with the "venture beyond" logo and three bullet points about how to work with them.

Shahbaz Khokhar: And the last thing, just plug working with us. Like if you want to work with us, we do work on a pay per sale basis as an affiliate. So if you've already got an ad account running and you want us to run in tandem to you, we want us to do some additional work and you're already spending like at least 100k a month, uh at a bare minimum. Um we're looking to we're looking to take on more affiliate deals. And we can work as a full service agency if you're spending at least 100k a month. Um and we've also got agency ad accounts where we can give cash back. So that's my little plug. Um so if you want 5% cash back on agency ad accounts, you know, you basically get for every million you spend, you get 50k back, um which is always going to help and you can, you know, bump up your uh your targets if if you're getting that as well.

Slide titled "Find me on LinkedIn, Twitter & Whatsapp" with a photo of Shahbaz Khokhar and QR codes for his social media profiles.

Shahbaz Khokhar: Um and that's pretty much me, that's it. So that I know that was I blasted through as much stuff as I could as fast as possible. You can find me on X, you can find me on LinkedIn. If you really want to contact me urgently, there's my WhatsApp. I'm a bit nervous about putting my WhatsApp out there, but I do have a business one, so I switch it off after hours. Um you can hit me up on there. Um don't send me long messages, don't send me long voice notes, don't send me dodgy pictures, just like only hit me up if you want to talk about creative at scale or if you're doing something cool or you want to talk about Ad Sprint or whatever. Um I'm I'm keen to have a conversation, so I'm I'm open to that.

Evan Lee: And that's pretty much me done. I I think I've blasted through that. I don't know if I it's been like how many minutes? 52 minutes. Oh my god. I love taking Q&A as well by the way, so I've only got eight minutes for Q&A, which is a shame, but uh let's see what let's do.

Evan Lee: We're going to have to jump to the next one. But Shahbaz, you talk about this stuff so casually and it's just gems on gems on gems. You want to stop sharing your screen real quick?

Shahbaz Khokhar: Oh, sorry. Yeah.

Evan Lee: You're good. You're good. You're good. Man, holy gosh. Everyone in the chat is like, I could take a full day of this essentially. You crushed it, man. You crushed it.

Shahbaz Khokhar: Amazing. Thank you, man. I just I always want to just like contribute to the world, man, of e-commerce and see what other people are up to. So I'm I'm always game. Anyone wants to talk afterwards about this stuff, just hit me on WhatsApp or or wherever. I'm I'm always game for a chat.

Evan Lee: And then everyone else, like I said, check out the docs tab. Everything that Shahbaz had mentioned is all there, okay? So you want early access, you want all the docs, it's literally all there. So go check that out. Please, please, please. So Shahbaz, you want to do some rapid fire? Try to get some some

Shahbaz Khokhar: Go for it, man. Let's we'll go through some stuff.

Evan Lee: Okay, you've done a really good job of answering a lot of questions as you proceeded through your presentation. So I think I'm just going to stick to the ones where it's just a little bit different. And the first one is a recruiting question from Alex.

A yellow box with a comment from "Dima Vityukov": "If you have a team big enough couldn't you do all 3??".

Evan Lee: So would love some tips on recruiting folks for the data team? Is the question that Alex has.

Shahbaz Khokhar: Oh, I I can't say I specifically have an answer for this because I'm not a wizard at recruiting data people. It's just we've happened to upskill one guy who's still in the office, like he we managed to upskill a grad by just keep giving him spreadsheets and we keep giving him uh challenges in Looker Studio and he just learned SQL off his own back and he's just been amazing. He's been with us for like two, three years now. And so he kind of built himself up. And then we had somebody else who's based in Pakistan who basically just like has experience doing SQL, building databases. He's a developer. Um I can't say like I had a strategic way of like finding them. I just got introduced by an existing staff member to that person. So I don't have a really amazing answer for that one. Um but other recruitment in other areas I can probably help. Message me afterwards about that one. But yeah, hit me with the next question.

Evan Lee: Perfect. Systems combined with amazing people always seems to work well, I feel like as a common theme.

A yellow box with a comment from "Dima Vityukov": "Is it better to build your own "agency" of creators or use prebuilt service ones?".

Evan Lee: Okay, Dima has a Dima has a question. Shout out Dima here. So this is going back to the triangle you had of low cost, uh high production, and then just like high volume. So you were talking about picking two. If you have a big enough team, could you do all three?

Shahbaz Khokhar: It's a very theoretical question. I'd probably just say no because like you always have to compromise, right? It's just there's always some element of compromise in every industry this triangle exists. So like I'm going to I'm going to go with no.

Evan Lee: Dima also has another question talking about like the creators that you start to leverage. So is it better to build your own roster of people that you've built up through like recruiting on Instagram or do you lean heavier into the other services like an Insense?

Shahbaz Khokhar: I got it. Uh it depends on the client, depends on the project. So like if it's something new that we need, so for example like we had like um we're working with Jeep and they needed like a specific type of travel content creator that we didn't have on our books. Um so we had to go on Insense and put a new thing out there, right? Um but then we do have like a roster of people who work with on a regular basis. And honestly, the best thing I recommend is like have them in a WhatsApp group. It's super annoying to have a zillion notifications, but that's why I have two WhatsApps. I have one with like all my zillions of like groups with people. Um and one for just my like personal peace of mind where my mom messages me about like, have I eaten today and that kind of stuff. So like the the one one with business is basically has all the groups with content creators. We're probably in, I don't know, we're in like maybe 30, 40 groups with content creators easily.

Evan Lee: Nuts. Nuts. Last one here and then we'll then we'll wrap it up.

A yellow box with a comment from "J L": "How do you deal with unreliable creators holding up production (i.e., late work, poor work, not following instructions)?".

Evan Lee: So it's just dealing, JL asks, how do you deal with unreliable creators holding up production, late work, poor work, not following instructions? You have your KPIs, but what do you do when things don't happen the way you want?

Shahbaz Khokhar: I'm not going to swear, but don't work with them again. I had an answer in my head, but it didn't it didn't come out because I'm like, there's too many people listening here. My mom's going to watch afterwards, so I've got to like, sorry, mom. Yeah, just don't work with them again. Honestly, it's just it's just about like, when you start working with people on a regular basis, you get to know who are the good ones and who are the slow ones. We don't have a bulletproof way of like holding them to account in the way in the same way we have with our internal team because with our internal team, I'll be like, yo, why haven't you done the work yet? Okay, I'm doing it. Content creator, oh, why haven't you done the work yet? Oh, sorry, I haven't done it. Oh, you know, I'm busy doing blah, blah, blah. You can't hold them to account in the same way. Um I think eventually we'll probably give people specific SLAs and say, okay, you got to we do say to people, hey, give us the content within two days normally. Um they don't always hit it. The ones who are good do consistently hit it. And the thing that speeds it up is the WhatsApp groups. I can't say this enough, but like just pinging them the brief in WhatsApp. And what I have is I have my content creator uh team assistant in the WhatsApp group. So she can put the brief that's gone in by the creative strategist into our system. So like I'm kind of using WhatsApp as like a unsystematic way of doing things to communicate fast with the content creators, but I've got an assistant in every single group that extracts the brief, puts it into Ad Sprint, make sure it gets done, and then make sure it gets paid, puts the budget in there and all that kind of stuff.

Evan Lee: I love it. Oh my gosh. Shahbaz, I think it's so cool because like I think we've known each other for what, like three years now maybe, surprisingly, over time. And just everyone in the chat, just know like watching this, I I know where this started, you know what I mean? And like the systems are so much more impressive today. So you see like the the skill evolve over time. So man, shout out to you. Thank you for sharing so much with the community today, man.

Shahbaz Khokhar: Thank you, man. I appreciate it. I've been working on this every single day of my life for the last three, four years since we first met. So like I'm hoping it's improving.